Stokking R, van Isselt J W, van Rijk P P, de Klerk J M, Huiskes A W, Mertens I J, Buskens E, Viergever M A
Image Sciences Institute, Utrecht University, University Hospital, The Netherlands.
J Nucl Med. 1999 Feb;40(2):311-6.
Two-dimensional SPECT display and three methods for integrated visualization of SPECT and MRI patient data are evaluated in a multiobserver study to determine whether localization of functional data can be improved by adding anatomical information to the display.
SPECT and MRI data of 30 patients were gathered and presented using four types of display: one of SPECT in isolation, two integrated two-dimensional displays and one integrated three-dimensional display. Cold and hot spots in the peripheral cortex were preselected and indicated on black-and-white hard copies of the image data. Nuclear medicine physicians were asked to assign the corresponding spots in the image data on the computer screen to a lobe and a gyrus and give a confidence rating for both localizations. Interobserver agreement using kappa statistics and average confidence ratings were assessed to interpret the reported observations.
Both the interobserver agreement and the confidence of the observers were greater for the integrated two-dimensional displays than for the two-dimensional SPECT display. An additional increase in agreement and confidence was seen with the integrated three-dimensional display.
Integrated display of SPECT and MR brain images provides better localization of cerebral blood perfusion abnormalities in the peripheral cortex in relation to the anatomy of the brain than single-modality display and increases the confidence of the observer.
在一项多观察者研究中评估了二维单光子发射计算机断层显像(SPECT)显示以及SPECT与磁共振成像(MRI)患者数据的三种综合可视化方法,以确定通过在显示中添加解剖学信息是否可以改善功能数据的定位。
收集了30例患者的SPECT和MRI数据,并使用四种类型的显示进行呈现:一种是单独的SPECT显示,两种综合二维显示和一种综合三维显示。预先选择外周皮质中的冷点和热点,并在图像数据的黑白硬拷贝上进行标注。要求核医学医师在计算机屏幕上的图像数据中为脑叶和脑回指定相应的点,并对两种定位给出置信度评分。使用kappa统计量评估观察者间的一致性以及平均置信度评分,以解释所报告的观察结果。
综合二维显示的观察者间一致性和观察者的置信度均高于二维SPECT显示。综合三维显示的一致性和置信度进一步提高。
与单模态显示相比,SPECT和MR脑图像的综合显示能更好地将外周皮质的脑血流灌注异常与脑解剖结构相关联进行定位,并提高观察者的置信度。