García-González A, Ochoa J L
Instituto Mexicano de Seguro Social, IMSS, La Paz, Baja California Sur, México.
Arch Med Res. 1999 Jan-Feb;30(1):69-73. doi: 10.1016/s0188-0128(98)00005-0.
Cu,Zn-superoxide-dismutase, Cu,Zn-SOD, can be obtained from different sources with different anti-inflammatory activities. In this study we compared the anti-inflammatory capacity of the marine yeast Debaryomyces hanseii Cu,Zn-SOD (Dh-SOD) with that of bovine erythrocytes (Be-SOD) in a preventive and a therapeutic fashion.
Edema was induced by carrageenan injection into the rat hind paw and was evaluated using a mercury plethysmograph. Development of the inflammatory process was followed by volume displacement at time 0 (carrageenan injection), 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 12, and 24 h thereafter. Three different SOD doses were used in preliminary experiments to prevent edema: 10, 100, and 1,000 U/kg.
The results indicate that, at the lowest dose (10 U/kg), both SOD samples are effective in reducing inflammation in both the prostaglandin and amplification phases (-24.8% and -17.5% in the case of Be-SOD, and 11.8% and -18.7% in the case of Dh-SOD, respectively) (p < 0.05). At 100 U/kg, Be-SOD also shows good anti-inflammatory activity in all edema phase (-27.1% in the serotonin phase; -19.4% in the prostaglandin phase; and -20% in the amplification phase) (p < 0.05), but Dh-SOD was less effective (-10.9%, -9.1%, and -5.7%). At the highest dose tested (1000 U/kg), Dh-SOD was, again, more effective than Be-SOD in all three edema phases (-33.1% and -1.5%; -17.9% and -2.6%; and -13.8% and 6.7%, respectively) (p < 0.05). When evaluated as a therapeutic alternative, single doses of Dh-SOD at 1,000 U/kg, and Be-SOD at 100 U/kg, both showed good anti-inflammatory activities (-31.7% and -23.5%, respectively) (p < 0.05).
For therapy purposes alone, Dh-SOD appears to be a better anti-inflammatory agent than Be-SOD in carrageenan-induced edema.
铜锌超氧化物歧化酶(Cu,Zn-SOD)可从不同来源获得,具有不同的抗炎活性。在本研究中,我们以预防和治疗方式比较了海洋酵母汉逊德巴利酵母Cu,Zn-SOD(Dh-SOD)与牛红细胞Cu,Zn-SOD(Be-SOD)的抗炎能力。
通过向大鼠后爪注射角叉菜胶诱导水肿,并用汞体积描记器进行评估。在注射角叉菜胶后的0(注射角叉菜胶时)、1、2、3、4、5、6、9、12和24小时,通过体积变化跟踪炎症过程的发展。在初步实验中使用三种不同剂量的SOD预防水肿:10、100和1000 U/kg。
结果表明,在最低剂量(10 U/kg)时,两种SOD样品在前列腺素和放大阶段均能有效减轻炎症(Be-SOD分别为-24.8%和-17.5%,Dh-SOD分别为11.8%和-18.7%)(p<0.05)。在100 U/kg时,Be-SOD在所有水肿阶段也表现出良好的抗炎活性(血清素阶段为-27.1%;前列腺素阶段为-19.4%;放大阶段为-20%)(p<0.05),但Dh-SOD效果较差(-10.9%、-9.1%和-5.7%)。在测试的最高剂量(1000 U/kg)下,Dh-SOD在所有三个水肿阶段再次比Be-SOD更有效(分别为-33.1%和-1.5%;-17.9%和-2.6%;-13.8%和6.7%)(p<0.05)。当作为治疗选择进行评估时,1000 U/kg的单剂量Dh-SOD和100 U/kg的Be-SOD均表现出良好的抗炎活性(分别为-31.7%和-23.5%)(p<0.05)。
仅就治疗目的而言,在角叉菜胶诱导的水肿中,Dh-SOD似乎比Be-SOD是更好的抗炎剂。