Buckingham J M, Howard F M, Bernatz P E, Payne W S, Harrison E G, O'Brien P C, Weiland L H
Ann Surg. 1976 Oct;184(4):453-8. doi: 10.1097/00000658-197610000-00008.
In the absence of a prospective randomized study of patients treated conservatively or with thymectomy, a computer-assisted retrospective matches study was devised. Of 563 patients treated for myasthenia gravis without thymoma up to 1965, 104 had thymectomy. With computer assistance, each surgical patient was matched with a medical patient on the basis of age, sex, and severity and duration of disease. On this basis 80 of the 104 surgical patients could be matched satisfactorily. There were 16 males and 64 females in each of the matched surgically treated and medical control groups. A complete remission was experienced by 27 of the 78 patients in the surgical group as compared to 6 of the medical group. Improvement was noted by 26 of 78 surgically treated patients and 13 of 78 receiving medical treatment. Survival for patients having thymectomy. Thirty-four patients in the medical group had died as compared to 11 in the surgical group. Comparison of survival in relation to sex, duration of symptoms, or age (less than 30 or less than 30 years) did not show a significant difference. Until more effective treatment is available for myasthenia gravis, thymectomy deserves consideration for both sexes, and with increased age or long duration of symptoms.
由于缺乏对接受保守治疗或胸腺切除术患者的前瞻性随机研究,因此设计了一项计算机辅助回顾性匹配研究。在截至1965年接受治疗的563例无胸腺瘤重症肌无力患者中,104例行胸腺切除术。在计算机辅助下,根据年龄、性别、疾病严重程度和病程,将每例手术患者与一名内科治疗患者进行匹配。在此基础上,104例手术患者中的80例能够得到满意匹配。在匹配的手术治疗组和内科对照组中,每组均有16例男性和64例女性。手术组78例患者中有27例完全缓解,而内科组为6例。78例接受手术治疗的患者中有26例病情改善,78例接受内科治疗的患者中有13例病情改善。胸腺切除术患者的生存率。内科组有34例患者死亡,而手术组为11例。按性别、症状持续时间或年龄(小于30岁或大于等于30岁)比较生存率,未显示出显著差异。在有更有效的重症肌无力治疗方法之前,胸腺切除术值得男女患者考虑,尤其是年龄较大或症状持续时间较长的患者。