Christensson D, Säveland H, Zygmunt S, Jonsson K, Rydholm U
Department of Orthopedics, University Hospital, Lund, Sweden.
J Neurosurg. 1999 Apr;90(2 Suppl):186-90. doi: 10.3171/spi.1999.90.2.0186.
The authors performed a prospective study to determine whether cervical laminectomy without simultaneous fusion results in spinal instability.
Because of clinical and radiographic signs of cord compression, 15 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (including one with Bechterew's disease) and severe involvement of the cervical spine underwent decompressive laminectomy without fusion performed on one or more levels. Preoperative flexion-extension radiographs demonstrated dislocation but no signs of instability at the level of cord compression. Clinical and radiological reexamination were performed twice at a median of 15 months (6-24 months) and 43 months (28-72 months) postoperatively. One patient developed severe vertical translocation 28 months after undergoing a C-1 laminectomy, which led to sudden tetraplegia. She required reoperation in which posterior fusion was performed. No signs of additional instability at the operated levels were found in the remaining 14 patients. In three patients increased but stable dislocation was demonstrated. The results of clinical examination were favorable in most patients, with improvement of neurological symptoms and less pain.
The authors conclude that decompressive laminectomy in which the facet joints are preserved can be performed in the rheumatoid arthritis-affected cervical spine in selected patients in whom signs of cord compression are demonstrated, but in whom radiographic and preoperative signs of instability are not. Performing a simultaneous fusion procedure does not always appear necessary. Vertical translocation must be detected early, and if present, a C-1 laminectomy should be followed by occipitocervical fusion.
作者进行了一项前瞻性研究,以确定不进行同期融合的颈椎椎板切除术是否会导致脊柱不稳定。
由于存在脊髓受压的临床和影像学征象,15例类风湿关节炎患者(包括1例贝赫切特病患者)且颈椎严重受累,接受了一个或多个节段的减压性椎板切除术且未进行融合。术前屈伸位X线片显示有脱位,但在脊髓受压节段无不稳定征象。术后分别于中位时间15个月(6 - 24个月)和43个月(28 - 72个月)进行了两次临床和影像学复查。1例患者在接受C - 1椎板切除术后28个月出现严重垂直移位,导致突然四肢瘫痪。她需要再次手术并进行后路融合。其余14例患者在手术节段未发现额外不稳定的征象。3例患者显示脱位增加但稳定。大多数患者临床检查结果良好,神经症状改善,疼痛减轻。
作者得出结论,对于有脊髓受压征象但无影像学和术前不稳定征象的选定类风湿关节炎累及颈椎患者,可以进行保留小关节的减压性椎板切除术。同期进行融合手术并非总是必要的。必须早期检测到垂直移位,若存在垂直移位,C - 1椎板切除术后应进行枕颈融合。