Baarends E M, van Marken Lichtenbelt W D, Wouters E F, Schols A M
Department of Pulmonology and Human Biology, Maastricht, University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Clin Nutr. 1998 Feb;17(1):15-22. doi: 10.1016/s0261-5614(98)80038-1.
It was previously demonstrated that single frequency bio-electrical impedance (BIA) measurement at 50 kHz is a useful method to assess total body water (TBW) in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). In the present study it was examined whether bio-electrical impedance spectroscopy (BIS) could predict extracellular water (ECW) and improve the prediction of TBW in these patients. TBW and ECW (corrected bromide space) were measured by deuterium and bromide dilution. In 37 COPD patients prediction equations were obtained using BIS (5-500 kHz) measurements, and these were cross validated in a second group of 40 COPD patients. All patients were in a clinically stable condition. TBW predicted by BIS was not significantly different from actual TBW and demonstrated a comparable standard error of estimate (SEE) as found previously in healthy subjects (male symbol correlation coefficient: r = 0.88, SEE: 2.3 L, female symbol r = 0.85, SEE: 2.9 L). Predicted ECW using BIS-measurements was not significantly different from measured ECW (male symbol r = 0.75, SEE: 1.4 L, female symbol r = 0.73, SEE: 1.2 L), but the error in the prediction was relatively large and the correlation between predicted and actual ECW relatively low compared to most studies in healthy subjects. Predicted TBW using BIS was comparable to actual TBW, but presented no improvement of the prediction of TBW using BIA at 50 kHz and a patient specific regression equation. The error of the prediction of ECW by BIS limits the ability to predict fluid shifts in individual patients with clinically stable COPD.
先前的研究表明,50 kHz 的单频生物电阻抗(BIA)测量是评估慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)患者全身水含量(TBW)的一种有用方法。在本研究中,研究了生物电阻抗光谱法(BIS)是否可以预测细胞外液(ECW)并改善对这些患者 TBW 的预测。通过氘和溴化物稀释法测量 TBW 和 ECW(校正后的溴化物空间)。在 37 例 COPD 患者中,使用 BIS(5 - 500 kHz)测量获得预测方程,并在第二组 40 例 COPD 患者中进行交叉验证。所有患者均处于临床稳定状态。BIS 预测的 TBW 与实际 TBW 无显著差异,并且显示出与先前在健康受试者中发现的相当的估计标准误差(SEE)(男性符号相关系数:r = 0.88,SEE:2.3 L,女性符号 r = 0.85,SEE:2.9 L)。使用 BIS 测量预测的 ECW 与测量的 ECW 无显著差异(男性符号 r = 0.75,SEE:1.4 L,女性符号 r = 0.73,SEE:1.2 L),但与大多数健康受试者研究相比,预测误差相对较大,预测的与实际的 ECW 之间的相关性相对较低。使用 BIS 预测的 TBW 与实际 TBW 相当,但与使用 50 kHz 的 BIA 和患者特异性回归方程预测 TBW 相比,并未有所改善。BIS 对 ECW 的预测误差限制了预测临床稳定的 COPD 个体患者液体转移的能力。