Kulhara P, Basu D, Mattoo S K, Sharan P, Chopra R
Department of Psychiatry, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
J Affect Disord. 1999 Jul;54(1-2):87-96. doi: 10.1016/s0165-0327(98)00145-1.
Discrepancy between efficacy of prophylactic lithium and its effectiveness in ordinary clinical practice necessitates long-term follow-up data from specialised lithium clinics. Also, role of psychosocial factors in influencing the outcome is unclear.
One hundred and eighteen patients of bipolar affective disorder attending a lithium clinic were followed-up for approximately 11 years (range 2-27 years). Demographic and clinical data, measures of social support and psychosocial stress were obtained at the intake in 1989-1990. Study design combined retrospective chart-review (till the time of intake) with prospective follow-up till July 1995.
On lithium, the patients had a mean of 0.43 relapses per year (manic, 0.26; depressive, 0.17) which was significantly less (p < 0.01) than the pre-lithium episode frequency. The figure for entirely relapse-free patients was 24%, and 62% had relapses up to one episode per year (median = 0.3 per year). Fifty-eight (49%) patients were good responders to lithium (relapses < or = 0.30 per year). In comparison to good responders, partial/poor responders had a significantly greater number of pre-lithium depressive episodes, poor lithium compliance, more psychosocial stress and lower social support at intake. These variables correlated well with relapses and explained 32% of the variance of the data.
Lithium had a definite prophylactic effect on long-term outcome. Social support and stressful life events are significant correlates of response to lithium.
Lithium prophylaxis of bipolar affective disorders seems justified though psychosocial factors appear to modulate its effectiveness.
Other psychotropic medications were used during relapse and the assessment of psychosocial factors was cross-sectional.
预防性使用锂盐的疗效与其在普通临床实践中的实际效果存在差异,这需要来自专业锂盐诊所的长期随访数据。此外,社会心理因素对治疗结果的影响作用尚不清楚。
对118名在锂盐诊所就诊的双相情感障碍患者进行了约11年(范围为2至27年)的随访。在1989 - 1990年患者就诊时获取了人口统计学和临床数据、社会支持及社会心理压力的测量数据。研究设计将回顾性病历审查(至就诊时)与前瞻性随访相结合,直至1995年7月。
服用锂盐期间,患者每年平均复发0.43次(躁狂发作0.26次,抑郁发作0.17次),这显著低于(p < 0.01)服用锂盐前的发作频率。完全无复发患者的比例为24%,62%的患者每年复发次数最多为1次(中位数 = 每年0.3次)。58名(49%)患者对锂盐反应良好(每年复发次数≤0.30次)。与反应良好者相比,部分反应者/反应不佳者在服用锂盐前有更多的抑郁发作、锂盐依从性差、更多的社会心理压力以及更低的社会支持。这些变量与复发密切相关,并解释了32%的数据方差。
锂盐对长期治疗结果有明确的预防作用。社会支持和应激性生活事件是对锂盐反应的重要相关因素。
尽管社会心理因素似乎会调节其效果,但锂盐预防双相情感障碍似乎是合理的。
复发期间使用了其他精神药物,且社会心理因素的评估为横断面研究。