Whitcomb M E, Anderson M B
Division of Medical Education, Association of American Medical Colleges, Washington, DC 20036-1125, USA.
Acad Med. 1999 Oct;74(10):1076-9. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199910000-00008.
In his book Time to Heal: American Medical Education from the Turn of the Century to the Era of Managed Care, Ludmerer expresses concern about the erosion of the environment in which medical students and residents learn the clinical skills, attitudes, and behaviors that they will need to practice high-quality medicine. Importantly, while he attributes the erosion of the clinical environment largely to the impact of managed care, he also places some responsibility within academic medicine itself, primarily the redirection of the clinical faculty's efforts away from traditional academic pursuits to the generation of clinical revenues. The Association of American Medical Colleges has information about the kinds of changes already occurring. In the preclinical curriculum, schools have introduced a wide range of new courses and topics, and there is more attention on professionalism and values. Schools are making fundamental changes in the design and conduct of the curriculum, primarily by adopting more integrated (non-departmental) approaches to course design and management. The clinical curriculum is changing primarily through the greatly expanded use of ambulatory care sites, and medical schools are developing new approaches to managing dispersed and varied instruction. Also, faculty are paying more attention to the role of residents as teachers and role models. These changes speak well for medical education. Nonetheless, substantial and sustained work remains to be done despite the present uncertainty about the future of academic medical centers. This work is essential--a challenge that the leaders of academic medicine must not fail.
在其著作《治愈时刻:从世纪之交到管理式医疗时代的美国医学教育》中,勒德梅勒对医学生和住院医师学习高质量医疗所需临床技能、态度和行为的环境遭到侵蚀表示担忧。重要的是,虽然他将临床环境的侵蚀主要归因于管理式医疗的影响,但他也认为学术医学本身也有一定责任,主要是临床教师的精力从传统学术追求转向了创收。美国医学院协会掌握着有关已发生的各类变化的信息。在基础课程方面,各学校开设了广泛的新课程和新主题,并且更加注重职业精神和价值观。学校正在对课程的设计与实施进行根本性变革,主要方式是在课程设计与管理中采用更综合(非按部门划分)的方法。临床课程的变化主要体现在门诊护理场所的使用大幅增加,医学院正在开发新方法来管理分散且多样的教学。此外,教师更加关注住院医师作为教师和榜样的作用。这些变化对医学教育来说是好事。尽管如此,尽管目前学术医疗中心的未来存在不确定性,但仍有大量且持续的工作要做。这项工作至关重要——学术医学领导者绝不能在这一挑战面前失败。