Sharma P, Kar H K, Misra R S, Mukherjee A, Kaur H, Mukherjee R, Rani R
National Institute of Immunology, New Delhi, India.
Int J Lepr Other Mycobact Dis. 1999 Sep;67(3):250-8.
A vaccine based on autoclaved Mycobacterium w was administered, in addition to standard multidrug therapy (MDT), to 157 bacteriologically positive, lepromin-negative, multibacillary leprosy patients supported by a well-matched control group of 147 patients with similar type of disease who received a placebo injection in addition to MDT. The MDT was given for a minimum period of 2 years and continued until skin-smear negativity, while the vaccine/placebo was given at 3-month intervals up to a maximum of 8 doses in the initial 2 years. The overall incidence of type 1 and type 2 reactions and neuritis during treatment and follow up was nearly equal in the patients in the vaccine and placebo groups; the differences were not statistically significant. The occurrence of disabilities, such as anesthesia, trophic ulcers, claw hand and grade 3 deformities, were not different statistically in the vaccine and placebo groups, an observation valid both for deformities present at induction and for those which developed during the course of therapy and surveillance. A statistically significant difference was observed in the recovery of newly developed trophic ulcers; recovery was quicker in the vaccine group. The recovery rate for motor deformities was marginally higher in the vaccine group, although not significant (p = 0.068) statistically. There was a statistically significant reduction in the incidence of grade 3 deformities following MDT with and without immunotherapy. To conclude, the addition of vaccine to MDT did not precipitate neuritis or deformities over and above that encountered with MDT alone, although it did accelerate bacteriological clearance, histopathological upgrading, conversion to lepromin positivity, and clinical improvement.
除标准多药疗法(MDT)外,还对157例细菌学阳性、麻风菌素阴性、多菌型麻风患者接种了基于高压灭菌的耻垢分枝杆菌的疫苗,并设立了一个匹配良好的对照组,该组有147例患有类似疾病的患者,除MDT外还接受了安慰剂注射。MDT至少给予2年,并持续至皮肤涂片转阴,而疫苗/安慰剂每3个月注射一次,在最初2年最多注射8剂。疫苗组和安慰剂组患者在治疗和随访期间1型和2型反应及神经炎的总体发生率几乎相等;差异无统计学意义。在疫苗组和安慰剂组中,残疾(如麻木、营养性溃疡、爪形手和3级畸形)的发生率在统计学上没有差异,这一观察结果对于诱导时出现的畸形以及治疗和监测过程中出现的畸形均有效。在新出现的营养性溃疡的恢复方面观察到有统计学意义的差异;疫苗组恢复更快。疫苗组运动畸形的恢复率略高,尽管在统计学上不显著(p = 0.068)。在接受MDT(无论有无免疫治疗)后,3级畸形的发生率有统计学意义的降低。总之,在MDT基础上加用疫苗并不会比单独使用MDT引发更多的神经炎或畸形,尽管它确实加速了细菌学清除、组织病理学改善、转化为麻风菌素阳性以及临床改善。