Kaur Inderjeet, Dogra Sunil, Kumar Bhushan, Radotra B D
Department of Dermatology, Venereology & Leprology, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh-160 012, India.
Int J Lepr Other Mycobact Dis. 2002 Sep;70(3):174-81.
A total of 136 patients with BI > or = 2 having been followed up for at least 2 years or more were included in the analyses. Seventy-seven out of 136 patients had completed three years follow up. All patients were given WHO/MDT MB regimen for 12 months and additionally 4 doses of Mycobacterium w. vaccine at 3-month intervals. The age of the patients varied from 6 to 77 years (mean 34 +/- 11.3 years) and they had the disease varying from 3 months to 7 years (mean = 1.9 +/- 1.4 years). The mean of the BI before starting treatment was 3.6 +/- 1.3. At the end of 2 years follow-up, a total of 54 patients out of the 136 (39.7%) had become smear-negative. A larger proportion of patients, 39/46 (84.8%) with BI of < or = 3 had become smear-negative, whereas, only 10/32 (31.3%) patients with BI between 3.1 to 4 and 5/58 (8.6%) highly bacillated patients having initial BI > 4 had become smear-negative at the end of 2 years. Out of the 77 patients who were available for follow up at 3 years, 30/33 (90.9%) patients with BI of < or = 3, 15/20 (75%) patients with BI between 3.1 to 4 and 13/24 (54.2%) patients having initial BI > 4, respectively, had attained smear negativity. Reactions occurred more frequently after 6 months of therapy and over a period of time their frequency gradually decreased, however, they continued to occur even two years after RFT. During the course of MDT and thereafter in follow up 4.6% and 1.3% of the patients developed new deformities or an increase in the existing grade of deformities, respectively. Three relapses (2 in LL and 1 in BL) occurred in patients having initial BI of > 4. One patient relapsed in the second year and the other two relapsed in the third year of follow up and were successfully treated with reintroduction of the same MDT MB regimen. Local ulceration healing with scar formation and regional lymphadenopathy were the only local reactions to the vaccine seen in 47/136 (34.5%) patients. All the patients showed histopathological improvement in the form of a gradual reduction of granuloma fraction. Although the results of this limited period follow up are satisfactory, a long-term follow-up in larger number of patients will settle the issue of safety and efficacy of shortened MDT MB regimen and the place of immunotherapy with M. w. vaccine in multibacillary patients.
共有136例BI≥2且随访至少2年及以上的患者纳入分析。136例患者中有77例完成了3年随访。所有患者均接受WHO/MDT MB方案治疗12个月,并额外每隔3个月接种4剂卡介苗。患者年龄从6岁到77岁不等(平均34±11.3岁),患病时间从3个月到7年不等(平均1.9±1.4年)。开始治疗前BI的平均值为3.6±1.3。在2年随访结束时,136例患者中有54例(39.7%)痰涂片转阴。BI≤3的患者中,39/46(84.8%)痰涂片转阴,而BI在3.1至4之间的患者中只有10/32(31.3%)痰涂片转阴,初始BI>4的高菌量患者中只有5/58(8.6%)在2年随访结束时痰涂片转阴。在77例可进行3年随访的患者中,BI≤3的患者中30/33(90.9%)、BI在3.1至4之间的患者中15/20(75%)以及初始BI>4的患者中13/24(54.2%)分别实现了痰涂片转阴。治疗6个月后反应更频繁出现,随着时间推移其频率逐渐降低,但即使在RFT后两年仍有反应发生。在MDT治疗期间及之后的随访中,分别有4.6%和1.3%的患者出现了新的畸形或现有畸形程度加重。初始BI>4的患者中有3例复发(2例在LL,1例在BL)。1例患者在第二年复发,另外2例在随访第三年复发,重新采用相同的MDT MB方案治疗后成功治愈。47/136(34.5%)的患者出现了局部溃疡愈合伴瘢痕形成以及局部淋巴结病,这是对疫苗仅有的局部反应。所有患者均表现出组织病理学改善,表现为肉芽肿比例逐渐降低。尽管这一有限时间段随访的结果令人满意,但对更多患者进行长期随访将解决缩短MDT MB方案的安全性和有效性以及卡介苗免疫疗法在多菌型患者中的地位问题。