Paterson J M, Allega R L
Department of Family Medicine, St Joseph's Community Health Centre, Hamilton, ON.
Can Fam Physician. 1999 Dec;45:2893-9.
To assess the timing, legibility, and completeness of handwritten, faxed hospital discharge summaries as judged by family physicians and to obtain their opinion on the information categories on a standardized discharge summary form.
Fax survey of physicians for consecutive patients discharged from hospital over 8 weeks.
Three wards in a tertiary care teaching hospital.
One hundred two family physicians and general practitioners practising in Hamilton, Ont.
Proportions of summaries that were received, received within 48 hours of discharge, legible, and complete; types of information missing from incomplete summaries; proportion of physicians satisfied with the information categories.
Of 271 consecutive patient discharges, 195 (72%) were eligible for study. Among those ineligible, 22 patients (8%) did not have a family doctor identified on their hospital records. Among records that did have a family physician identified, fax numbers were unavailable or unknown for 54 physicians (20%). One hundred two physicians completed 166 discharge summary assessments for a response rate of 85% (166/195). By 3 weeks after discharge, 138 discharge summaries (83%) had been received by patients' family doctors. Among those received, 86% were received within 48 hours of discharge; 92% were legible; and 88% were complete. Hospital doctors' signatures, patients' diagnoses, and follow-up plans were most frequently missing. Ninety-five percent of physicians were satisfied with the information categories included on the standardized form.
Handwritten, faxed hospital discharge summaries were acceptable to family physicians for most patients. Criteria are needed for determining which patients require both handwritten and dictated discharge summaries.
评估家庭医生对医院手写出院小结和传真出院小结的及时性、易读性和完整性,并获取他们对标准化出院小结表格中信息类别的看法。
对连续8周出院的患者的医生进行传真调查。
一家三级护理教学医院的三个病房。
安大略省汉密尔顿市的102名家庭医生和全科医生。
收到的小结比例、出院后48小时内收到的小结比例、易读的小结比例、完整的小结比例;不完整小结中缺失的信息类型;对信息类别的满意的医生比例。
在271例连续出院患者中,195例(72%)符合研究条件。在不符合条件的患者中,22例(8%)在医院记录中未确定家庭医生。在确定有家庭医生的记录中,54名医生(20%)的传真号码不可用或未知。102名医生完成了166份出院小结评估,回复率为85%(166/195)。出院后3周内,患者的家庭医生收到了138份出院小结(83%)。在收到的小结中,86%在出院后48小时内收到;92%易读;88%完整。医院医生签名、患者诊断和随访计划最常缺失。95%的医生对标准化表格中包含的信息类别感到满意。
对于大多数患者,家庭医生可以接受手写和传真的医院出院小结。需要制定标准来确定哪些患者既需要手写出院小结也需要口述出院小结。