Rosling B, Nyman S, Lindhe J, Jern B
J Clin Periodontol. 1976 Nov;3(4):233-50. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1976.tb00042.x.
A clinical trial was undertaken to study the healing capacity of the periodontal tissues following different modes of periodontal surgery in patients whose oral hygiene was professionally maintained at an optimal level. Fifty patients, distributed into five groups, participated in the study. Following an initial examination and presurgical treatment, the various patient groups were subjected to one of the following surgical procedures: 1) the apically repositioned flap operation including elimination of bony defects, 2) the apically repositioned flap operation including curettage of the bony defects but without removal of bone, 3) the "Widman flap" technique including elimination of bony defects, 4) the "Widman flap" technique including curettage of the bony defects but without removal of bone, 5) gingivectomy including curettage of the bony defects but without removal of bone. After surgery, all patients received oral hygiene instruction and professional cleaning of the teeth once every 2 weeks during a 2-year period. The results showed that periodontal disease can be cured and further destruction of the periodontal tissues avoided irrespective of the surgical technique utilized for pocket elimination. Different surgical techniques, however, promoted varying degrees of regeneration of the supporting tissues. The most favourable healing was obtained when resection of bone was avoided and when complete coverage of the alveolar bone was ensured.
一项临床试验旨在研究在口腔卫生由专业人员维持在最佳水平的患者中,不同牙周手术方式后牙周组织的愈合能力。五十名患者被分为五组参与了该研究。在进行初步检查和术前治疗后,各患者组接受了以下手术程序之一:1)根向复位瓣手术,包括消除骨缺损;2)根向复位瓣手术,包括刮治骨缺损但不切除骨;3)“威德曼瓣”技术,包括消除骨缺损;4)“威德曼瓣”技术,包括刮治骨缺损但不切除骨;5)牙龈切除术,包括刮治骨缺损但不切除骨。术后,所有患者在两年期间接受了口腔卫生指导,并每两周接受一次专业牙齿清洁。结果表明,无论采用何种手术技术消除牙周袋,牙周病都可以治愈,并且可以避免牙周组织的进一步破坏。然而,不同的手术技术促进了支持组织不同程度的再生。当避免切除骨并确保牙槽骨完全覆盖时,可获得最有利的愈合效果。