Sharp S E, Lemes M, Sierra S G, Poniecka A, Poppiti R J
Arkadi M. Rywlin Department of Pathology Mount Sinai Medical Center, Miami Beach, FL 33140, USA.
Am J Clin Pathol. 2000 Jun;113(6):770-3. doi: 10.1309/JHDD-1HF4-2KCN-7ANP.
Isolation of mycobacteria on Löwenstein-Jensen media (LJ) and in the BACTEC MB9000 (MB) system was compared. Of 2,271 specimens, 317 were positive for 331 mycobacteria isolated in 1 or both media. The MB was positive in 238 isolates, and LJ was positive for 239 isolates; 92 isolates were detected by MB only and 93 by LJ only. Of the 331 isolates, 146 were recovered by both media. MB recovered 38 of 38 Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates, while LJ recovered 23. MB recovered 94.1% (96/102) of Mycobacterium avium complex isolates and LJ 69.6% (71/102). The MB recovered 81% (65/80) Mycobacterium fortuitum-chelonae isolates and LJ 68% (54/80). Of the remaining species, MB isolated 39, while LJ isolated 91. Only 1 organism that was isolated on LJ alone was medically significant based on medical record review. The addition of LJ media to the MB9000 system is not warranted, as it causes clinically irrelevant workload, increased expenditures for the laboratory, and could cause the inappropriate treatment of patients.
比较了在罗-琴培养基(LJ)和BACTEC MB9000(MB)系统中分枝杆菌的分离情况。在2271份标本中,317份对1种或两种培养基中分离出的331株分枝杆菌呈阳性。MB检测出238株阳性,LJ检测出239株阳性;仅MB检测出92株,仅LJ检测出93株。在331株分离株中,两种培养基均回收了146株。MB回收了38株结核分枝杆菌复合群分离株中的38株,而LJ回收了23株。MB回收了102株鸟分枝杆菌复合群分离株中的94.1%(96/102),LJ回收了69.6%(71/102)。MB回收了80株偶发分枝杆菌-龟分枝杆菌复合群分离株中的81%(65/80),LJ回收了68%(54/80)。对于其余菌种,MB分离出39株,而LJ分离出91株。根据病历审查,仅在LJ上分离出的1株菌具有医学意义。在MB9000系统中添加LJ培养基没有必要,因为这会导致临床无关的工作量、增加实验室费用,并可能导致患者的不适当治疗。