Wangensteen O H, Wangensteen S D
Surgery. 1975 Mar;77(3):403-18.
The Surgical Amphitheatre, patterned after the earlier model of Anatomists, came into being in the 17th century and served the purpose of teaching the anatomy of operation to surgeons, but without hospital connections. A great decline of student and visitor interest in viewing operations attended disappearance of the gambler's risk of operations, followed at the turn of this century by a lesser interest of medical students in attending surgical lectures, a circumstance that provoked consternation in the ranks of surgical teachers. The demise of the surgical amphitheatre as a suitable site for surgical teaching and viewing operations marked the beginnings of a gradual decline of influence of surgery in medical school faculties. Acceptance by reluctant surgeons of the inescapable microbiologic principle that silence of the entire Operating Team is mandatory, when operations are in process, will obviously erode further usefulness of the operating arena for instruction of medical students. Over the past decade, the current sharpened focus upon dispersion of medical care has served to de-emphasize in our medical faculties the post-World War II stress upon research for medicine's advance. A gradual decrease of student interest in surgery has occasioned medical faculties to question the justification of continuing surgery as a major curricular discipline for undergraduate medical students. Surgeons need to cultivate the intimate teacher-student relationship reflected in the practices of Pierre Louis and William Osler. A critical reassessment by professors of surgery of their teaching responsibilities should serve to indicate to medical students and their faculties that surgery has much important and useful information to impart, and that their professors are ready, prepared, and anxious to meet the challenge.
外科手术观摩厅仿照早期解剖学家的模式,于17世纪应运而生,其目的是向外科医生传授手术解剖知识,但与医院并无关联。学生和访客对观摩手术的兴趣大幅下降,手术中类似赌博般的风险也随之消失,接着在本世纪之交,医学生对外科讲座的兴趣也有所降低,这一情况在外科学教师队伍中引起了恐慌。外科手术观摩厅作为外科教学和观摩手术的合适场所的衰落,标志着外科学在医学院系的影响力开始逐渐下降。不情愿的外科医生接受了不可避免的微生物学原则,即在手术进行时整个手术团队必须保持沉默,这显然会进一步削弱手术室对医学生教学的作用。在过去十年中,当前对医疗服务分散化的高度关注使得我们医学院系不再像二战后那样强调医学进步的研究。学生对外科手术兴趣的逐渐降低,促使医学院系质疑将外科学作为本科医学生主要课程学科的合理性。外科医生需要培养像皮埃尔·路易斯和威廉·奥斯勒的实践中所体现的那种亲密的师生关系。外科学教授对其教学职责进行批判性重新评估,应该向医学生及其所在院系表明,外科学有许多重要且有用的知识要传授,并且他们的教授已准备好、有能力且渴望迎接挑战。