Strömgren L S, Juul-Jensen P
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1975 Jun;51(5):340-60. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1975.tb00013.x.
The investigation concerned 100 patients with endogenous depression treated with ECT, 52 unilaterally on the non-dominant hemisphere, and 48 bilaterally. A double-blind investigation of the therapeutic effect and the effect on memory and on EEG was carried out. With unilateral treatment, mainly diffuse and same-sided EEG changes appeared, while with bilateral treatment mainly diffuse and left-sided changes occurred. Bilateral treatment led to significantly more EEG changes than did unilateral treatment. For both groups there was a tendency to greater changes after the last than after the sixth treatment. At termination of treatment, a significantly better therapeutic effect was found in cases where EEG changes appeared, especially severe EEG changes. This applied to the total material but not to the groups of unilaterals and bilaterals taken separately. In the entire material after the first six treatments, the greatest representation of patients with unchanged and impaired memory was found in cases with deteriorated EEG compared to cases with no EEG deterioration. After the entire series of ECT, this correlation no longer was present. After separation of the patients into unilaterals and bilaterals it was not present at any of the stages. In the bilateral group ECT treatment gave more frequent and stronger EEG changes, among the older than among the younger patients. For the unilateral group, there was no comparable difference. The number of weak seizures was significantly greater among the unilaterals than among the bilaterals. The therapeutic effect was not correlated to the number of weak seizures, but the number of weak seizures was positively correlated to the number of treatments applied.
该研究涉及100例接受电休克治疗(ECT)的内源性抑郁症患者,其中52例在非优势半球进行单侧治疗,48例进行双侧治疗。对治疗效果、对记忆和脑电图的影响进行了双盲研究。单侧治疗时,主要出现弥漫性且同侧的脑电图变化,而双侧治疗时主要出现弥漫性且左侧的变化。双侧治疗导致的脑电图变化明显多于单侧治疗。两组患者在最后一次治疗后比第六次治疗后都有更大变化的趋势。在治疗结束时,脑电图出现变化尤其是严重脑电图变化的病例中,治疗效果明显更好。这适用于总体病例,但不适用于分别的单侧和双侧治疗组。在前六次治疗后的整个病例中,与脑电图未恶化的病例相比,脑电图恶化的病例中记忆未改变和受损的患者比例最高。在整个电休克治疗系列之后,这种相关性不再存在。将患者分为单侧和双侧治疗组后,在任何阶段都不存在这种相关性。在双侧治疗组中,电休克治疗导致的脑电图变化在老年患者中比在年轻患者中更频繁、更强烈。对于单侧治疗组,没有类似的差异。单侧治疗组的弱发作次数明显多于双侧治疗组。治疗效果与弱发作次数无关,但弱发作次数与应用的治疗次数呈正相关。