Goodwin N
Manchester Health Authority, UK.
Health Policy. 2000 Feb;51(1):49-60. doi: 10.1016/s0168-8510(99)00072-x.
This paper explores future leadership requirements for health services in the context of relevant leadership theory and the changing environment for health services in the UK. The output of leadership research is both prolific and confusing and its applicability to health services management uncertain especially in the context of constraints on the strategic managerial behaviour and choices of public service managers. The introduction of general management to the UK NHS in the 1980s, followed by an internal market for health care in 1990 should have provided the opportunity for managers to work differently and to create personal space for leadership. However, it is not known whether sustainable , new ways of leadership working have emerged although it is reasonable to hypothesis from studies elsewhere that a number of contextual and behavioural leadership models are likely to be found in the NHS. Although management researchers have explored networking and referred to the impact of the external environment of leadership, insufficient importance has been attached to-date to the impact of future trends in health services on the leadership of change in the health sector. The paper argues that in future health services leadership will require much more than traditional networking with other organizations and groups and will need to focus on developing and securing external agreement to an agenda for positive change turning the apparent constraints of the external environment, determined primarily by government policies,into opportunities. In other words, the demands of external or contextual leadership will increase forcing a stronger focus on having to achieve change through others.
本文结合相关领导理论以及英国医疗服务不断变化的环境,探讨了未来医疗服务领域的领导力要求。领导力研究成果丰富却令人困惑,其在医疗服务管理中的适用性也不明确,尤其是在公共服务管理者的战略管理行为和选择受到限制的情况下。20世纪80年代英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)引入综合管理,随后在1990年引入医疗内部市场,这本应为管理者提供不同的工作方式并创造领导的个人空间。然而,目前尚不清楚是否已出现可持续的新领导工作方式,不过从其他地方的研究推测,NHS中可能会发现一些情境和行为领导模式,这是合理的。尽管管理研究人员探讨了网络关系并提及外部环境对领导力的影响,但迄今为止,医疗服务未来趋势对医疗行业变革领导力的影响尚未得到足够重视。本文认为,未来医疗服务领导力所需的远不止与其他组织和团体进行传统的网络联系,还需要专注于制定并确保外部认同一项积极变革议程,将主要由政府政策决定的外部环境的明显限制转化为机遇。换句话说,外部或情境领导力的要求将会增加,迫使人们更加强调通过他人来实现变革。