Tillman D J, Charland S L, Witt D M
Clinical Pharmacy Anticoagulation Service, Kaiser Permanente Colorado Region, Denver, USA.
Arch Intern Med. 2000 Oct 23;160(19):2926-32. doi: 10.1001/archinte.160.19.2926.
Controlled clinical trials have demonstrated that outpatient administration of low-molecular-weight heparin to patients with acute deep vein thrombosis (DVT) provides safety and efficacy equivalent to that of traditional inpatient therapy with unfractionated heparin. Whether favorable results reported in controlled clinical trials are achievable in clinical practice is an important consideration.
Appropriate patients with objectively diagnosed DVT were treated as outpatients with low-molecular-weight heparin and warfarin sodium according to an approved guideline. The primary end point for analysis consisted of objectively diagnosed symptomatic recurrent thromboembolism or major bleeding within a 90-day evaluation period. The incremental cost incurred by the organization while using the outpatient DVT treatment guideline was determined. Incremental cost savings of the outpatient DVT treatment program were determined based on the cost that would have accrued had the patient been admitted to the hospital for treatment with unfractionated heparin.
We enrolled 391 patients (91.4%) in the outpatient DVT treatment program. Of these, 373 (95.4%) completed 90 days of therapy without reaching the primary end point. The percentage of patients reaching the primary outcome measure (4.6%) fell within the range of patients enrolled in controlled clinical trials (3.5%-9.4%). During the 2-year program evaluation, total cost savings of $1,108,587 were realized.
Outpatient treatment of acute DVT can be managed safely and effectively in clinical practice. The potential savings associated with outpatient DVT treatment are substantial. Arch Intern Med. 2000;160:2926-2932
对照临床试验表明,对急性深静脉血栓形成(DVT)患者门诊给予低分子量肝素,其安全性和疗效与传统住院应用普通肝素治疗相当。在临床实践中能否取得对照临床试验报告的良好结果是一个重要的考量因素。
根据一项批准的指南,对客观诊断为DVT的合适患者门诊给予低分子量肝素和华法林钠治疗。分析的主要终点包括在90天评估期内客观诊断的有症状复发性血栓栓塞或严重出血。确定了机构在使用门诊DVT治疗指南时产生的增量成本。门诊DVT治疗方案的增量成本节约是根据患者若住院接受普通肝素治疗本应产生的成本来确定的。
我们将391例患者(91.4%)纳入门诊DVT治疗方案。其中,373例(95.4%)完成了90天治疗且未达到主要终点。达到主要结局指标的患者百分比(4.6%)落在对照临床试验纳入患者的范围内(3.5% - 9.4%)。在为期2年的方案评估期间,共实现成本节约1,108,587美元。
在临床实践中,急性DVT的门诊治疗可以安全有效地进行。门诊DVT治疗相关的潜在节约成本是巨大的。《内科学文献》。2000年;160:2926 - 2932