Krakauer J W, Pine Z M, Ghilardi M F, Ghez C
Departments of Neurology and Neurobiology and Behavior, Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, New York 10032, USA.
J Neurosci. 2000 Dec 1;20(23):8916-24. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.20-23-08916.2000.
The planning of visually guided reaches is accomplished by independent specification of extent and direction. We investigated whether this separation of extent and direction planning for well practiced movements could be explained by differences in the adaptation to extent and directional errors during motor learning. We compared the time course and generalization of adaptation with two types of screen cursor transformation that altered the relationship between hand space and screen space. The first was a gain change that induced extent errors and required subjects to learn a new scaling factor. The second was a screen cursor rotation that induced directional errors and required subjects to learn new reference axes. Subjects learned a new scaling factor at the same rate when training with one or multiple target distances, whereas learning new reference axes took longer and was less complete when training with multiple compared with one target direction. After training to a single target, subjects were able to transfer learning of a new scaling factor to previously unvisited distances and directions. In contrast, generalization of rotation adaptation was incomplete; there was transfer across distances and arm configurations but not across directions. Learning a rotated reference frame only occurred after multiple target directions were sampled during training. These results suggest the separate processing of extent and directional errors by the brain and support the idea that reaching movements are planned as a hand-centered vector whose extent and direction are established via learning a scaling factor and reference axes.
视觉引导伸手动作的规划是通过对范围和方向的独立设定来完成的。我们研究了对于熟练动作,范围和方向规划的这种分离是否可以用运动学习过程中对范围和方向误差适应的差异来解释。我们用两种改变手部空间和屏幕空间关系的屏幕光标变换,比较了适应的时间进程和泛化情况。第一种是增益变化,它会引发范围误差,要求受试者学习一个新的缩放因子。第二种是屏幕光标旋转,它会引发方向误差,要求受试者学习新的参考轴。当用一个或多个目标距离进行训练时,受试者学习新缩放因子的速度相同,而与一个目标方向相比,用多个目标方向训练时,学习新参考轴所需时间更长且不太完整。在对单个目标进行训练后,受试者能够将新缩放因子的学习迁移到之前未探索过的距离和方向。相比之下,旋转适应的泛化并不完整;存在跨距离和手臂配置的迁移,但不存在跨方向的迁移。只有在训练期间对多个目标方向进行采样后,才会出现对旋转参考系的学习。这些结果表明大脑对范围和方向误差进行了单独处理,并支持这样一种观点,即伸手动作被规划为一个以手部为中心的向量,其范围和方向是通过学习缩放因子和参考轴来确定的。