McKenzie K, Samele C, Van Horn E, Tattan T, Van Os J, Murray R
Haringey Healthcare Trust and University Department of Psychiatry, Royal Free and University College Medical Schools, Royal Free Hospital, Rowland Hill Street, London NW3 2PF, UK.
Br J Psychiatry. 2001 Feb;178:160-5. doi: 10.1192/bjp.178.2.160.
The comparative outcome of psychosis in British Whites and UK African-Caribbeans is unclear. Some report that African-Caribbeans have worse outcome, whereas others claim better symptomatic outcome and a more benign course.
To compare the course, outcome and treatment of psychosis in African-Caribbeans and British Whites in a large multi-centre sample.
A secondary analysis of 708 patients with research diagnostic criteria-defined psychosis from a 2-year, randomised controlled trial of case management. Outcome measures (hospitalisation, illness course, self-harm, social disability and treatment received) were adjusted for socio-economic and clinical differences between groups at baseline using regression analysis.
African-Caribbeans were less likely to have a continuous illness and to receive treatment with antidepressant or psychotherapy.
The outcome of psychosis is complex but differs between UK African-Caribbeans and British Whites. This may reflect risk factors that increase the rate of psychosis in UK African-Caribbeans. Treatment differences require further investigation.
英国白人和英国非裔加勒比人中精神病的比较结果尚不清楚。一些报告称非裔加勒比人的预后较差,而另一些人则声称其症状预后较好且病程更良性。
在一个大型多中心样本中比较非裔加勒比人和英国白人中精神病的病程、结局和治疗情况。
对一项为期两年的病例管理随机对照试验中708例符合研究诊断标准的精神病患者进行二次分析。使用回归分析对基线时两组之间的社会经济和临床差异调整结局指标(住院、病程、自残、社会残疾和接受的治疗)。
非裔加勒比人患持续性疾病的可能性较小,接受抗抑郁药或心理治疗的可能性也较小。
精神病的结局很复杂,但在英国非裔加勒比人和英国白人之间存在差异。这可能反映了增加英国非裔加勒比人精神病发病率的危险因素。治疗差异需要进一步研究。