Cocco G, Strozzi C, Chu D, Amrein R, Castagnoli E
Eur J Cardiol. 1979 Jul;10(1):59-69.
A single blind randomized parallel study designed to assess the anti-anginal efficacy of pindolol and nifedipine was carried out in 42 ambulatory coronary patients with stable angina pectoris. Drug efficacy was assessed in terms of (a) pain, (b) frequency of anginal episodes, (c) nitroglycerin consumption, (d) exercise tolerance and (e) ST-segment changes. The effect of these drugs on asymptomatic resting myocardial ischemia was also assessed by means of 24-h dynamic electrocardiography (DCG). All patients were checked at weekly intervals. At the end of a 4-wk placebo period, the patients were randomly assigned either to the pindolol or nifedipine group. The treatment lasted for 45 days. During the placebo period, ischemic ECG changes and symptoms of coronary insufficiency were detected in all patients. Furthermore, 12 out of 42 patients had asymptomatic myocardial ischemia at rest. One patient from each group was dropped because of tolerance. At the end of the 45-day study, pindolol and nifedipine were equi-effective on spontaneous and effort-related angina. There were, however, some differences: increased tolerance to exercise appeared earlier with pindolol: the pindolol group showed a slightly reduced while the nifedipine group showed a slightly increased heart rate. Furthermore, nifedipine reduced or eliminated asymptomatic myocardial ischemia in 6 out of 7 patients while only 1 out of 5 improved in the pindolol group.
一项单盲随机平行研究旨在评估吲哚洛尔和硝苯地平对心绞痛的疗效,该研究在42例门诊稳定型心绞痛冠心病患者中进行。药物疗效通过以下方面进行评估:(a)疼痛,(b)心绞痛发作频率,(c)硝酸甘油消耗量,(d)运动耐量,以及(e)ST段变化。还通过24小时动态心电图(DCG)评估了这些药物对无症状静息性心肌缺血的影响。所有患者每周检查一次。在为期4周的安慰剂期结束时,患者被随机分配到吲哚洛尔组或硝苯地平组。治疗持续45天。在安慰剂期,所有患者均检测到缺血性心电图变化和冠状动脉供血不足症状。此外,42例患者中有12例存在无症状静息性心肌缺血。每组有1例患者因耐受性而退出。在为期45天的研究结束时,吲哚洛尔和硝苯地平对自发性和劳力性心绞痛疗效相当。然而,存在一些差异:吲哚洛尔组运动耐量增加出现得更早;吲哚洛尔组心率略有降低,而硝苯地平组心率略有升高。此外,硝苯地平使7例患者中的6例无症状心肌缺血减轻或消除,而吲哚洛尔组5例中只有1例有所改善。