Hall G C, Maramba G G
Department of Psychology, 333 Moore Building, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania 16802, USA.
Cultur Divers Ethnic Minor Psychol. 2001 Feb;7(1):12-26. doi: 10.1037/1099-9809.7.1.12.
The purpose of this study was to identify where the most work on cross-cultural and ethnic minority psychology is being published and who the most productive authors are. The journals that published the most articles on cross-cultural and ethnic minority issues from 1993 to 1999 and the most prolific authors on these issues were identified by PsycINFO. Cross-cultural research is cross-national, whereas ethnic minority research involves groups of color within the United States. The citation impact of these journals and authors was determined from the 1997 Social Sciences Citation Index. The results suggest that there is very limited overlap between the literatures in cross-cultural and ethnic minority psychology. Most of the research in these areas is published in specialty journals, and there is a paucity of this research in prestigious journals. Perceived or actual barriers to publication in prestigious journals may cause some to seek specialty journals as outlets for research on cultural diversity. The top scholars in cross-cultural psychology are primarily men of European ancestry, whereas most of the top scholars in ethnic minority psychology are ethnic minority men and women. Strategies to increase the prominence of cultural diversity in the psychology literature include combining cross-cultural and ethnic minority psychology, increasing the number of editorial board members of prestigious journals having expertise in cultural diversity, and increasing the quality of specialty journals. Psychology will remain ill-equipped to face the challenges of the new millennium without increased attention to cultural diversity.
本研究的目的是确定跨文化和少数族裔心理学领域的大部分研究成果发表在哪些地方,以及最具生产力的作者是谁。通过心理学文摘数据库(PsycINFO)确定了1993年至1999年发表关于跨文化和少数族裔问题文章最多的期刊以及这些问题上最多产的作者。跨文化研究是跨国的,而少数族裔研究涉及美国境内的有色人种群体。这些期刊和作者的被引影响力是根据1997年《社会科学引文索引》确定的。结果表明,跨文化心理学和少数族裔心理学的文献之间重叠非常有限。这些领域的大部分研究发表在专业期刊上,而在著名期刊上这类研究很少。在著名期刊上发表文章存在的可感知或实际障碍可能导致一些人寻求专业期刊作为文化多样性研究的发表渠道。跨文化心理学领域的顶尖学者主要是欧洲裔男性,而少数族裔心理学领域的顶尖学者大多是少数族裔男性和女性。提高文化多样性在心理学文献中地位的策略包括将跨文化心理学和少数族裔心理学结合起来、增加在文化多样性方面具有专业知识的著名期刊编辑委员会成员数量以及提高专业期刊的质量。如果不更加关注文化多样性,心理学将仍然无法应对新千年的挑战。