Givel M S, Glantz S A
University of California San Francisco, Institute for Health Policy Studies and Cardiovascular Research Institute, Department of Medicine, San Francisco, California, USA.
Tob Control. 2001 Jun;10(2):124-34. doi: 10.1136/tc.10.2.124.
Throughout the 1990s the tobacco lobby was a potent political force in US state legislatures advancing its pro-tobacco agenda.
To describe the market and political motivations of the tobacco lobby and the strategies they use to achieve these goals in US state legislatures.
This study is a content analysis and summary overview of recently released historical tobacco industry documents; tobacco related government documents; and recent state tobacco control policy reports.
In the 1990s, the tobacco lobby engaged in a comprehensive and aggressive political effort in state legislatures to sell tobacco with the least hindrance using lobbying, the media, public relations, front groups, industry allies, and contributions to legislators. These efforts included campaigns to neutralise clean indoor air legislation, minimise tax increases, and preserve the industry's freedom to advertise and sell tobacco. The tobacco lobby succeeded in increasing the number of states that enacted state pre-emption of stricter local tobacco control laws and prevented the passage of many state tobacco control policies. Public health advocates were able to prevent pre-emption and other pro-tobacco policies from being enacted in several states.
The tobacco lobby is a powerful presence in state legislatures. Because of the poor public image of the tobacco lobby, it seeks to wield this power quietly and behind the scenes. State and local health advocates, who often have high public credibility, can use this fact against the tobacco lobby by focusing public attention on the tobacco lobby's political influence and policy goals and expose links between the tobacco lobby and its legislative supporters.
在整个20世纪90年代,烟草游说团体在美国各州立法机构中是一股强大的政治力量,推动其支持烟草的议程。
描述烟草游说团体的市场和政治动机,以及他们在美国各州立法机构中为实现这些目标所采用的策略。
本研究是对最近发布的历史烟草行业文件、与烟草相关的政府文件以及近期的州烟草控制政策报告进行的内容分析和概述。
在20世纪90年代,烟草游说团体在各州立法机构中展开了全面且积极的政治活动,通过游说、媒体、公共关系、前沿团体、行业盟友以及对立法者的捐款,以最少的阻碍销售烟草产品。这些努力包括开展活动以抵消室内空气清洁立法的影响、尽量减少税收增加,并维护该行业宣传和销售烟草的自由。烟草游说团体成功增加了颁布州一级优先适用更严格地方烟草控制法律的州的数量,并阻止了许多州烟草控制政策的通过。公共卫生倡导者在几个州成功阻止了优先适用及其他支持烟草的政策的颁布。
烟草游说团体在各州立法机构中势力强大,但由于其公众形象不佳而试图在幕后悄悄行使这种权力。州和地方卫生倡导者通常具有较高的公众可信度,可以利用这一点,通过让公众关注烟草游说团体的政治影响力和政策目标,并揭露烟草游说团体与其立法支持者之间的联系,来对抗烟草游说团体。