Booth M L, Okely A D, Chey T, Bauman A
NSW Centre for the Advancement of Adolescent Health, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, University of Sydney at The Children's Hospital at Westmead, New South Wales, Australia.
Br J Sports Med. 2001 Aug;35(4):263-7. doi: 10.1136/bjsm.35.4.263.
To assess the test-retest reliability and validity of the physical activity questions in the World Health Organisation health behaviour in schoolchildren (WHO HBSC) survey.
In the validity study, the Multistage Fitness Test was administered to a random sample of year 8 (mean age 13.1 years; n = 1072) and year 10 (mean age 15.1 years; n = 954) high school students from New South Wales (Australia) during February/March 1997. The students completed the self report instruments on the same day. An independent sample of year 8 (n = 121) and year 10 (n = 105) students was used in the reliability study. The questionnaire was administered to the same students on two occasions, two weeks apart, and test-retest reliability was assessed. Students were classified as either active or inadequately active on their combined responses to the questionnaire items. Kappa and percentage agreement were assessed for the questionnaire items and for a two category summary measure.
All groups of students (boys and girls in year 8 and year 10) classified as active (regardless of the measure) had significantly higher aerobic fitness than students classified as inadequately active. As a result of highly skewed binomial distributions, values of kappa were much lower than percentage agreement for test-retest reliability of the summary measure. For year 8 boys and girls, percentage agreement was 67% and 70% respectively, and for year 10 boys and girls percentage agreement was 85% and 70% respectively.
These brief self report questions on participation in vigorous intensity physical activity appear to have acceptable reliability and validity. These instruments need to be tested in other cultures to ensure that the findings are not specific to Australian students. Further refinement of the measures should be considered.
评估世界卫生组织学龄儿童健康行为调查(WHO HBSC)中身体活动问题的重测信度和效度。
在效度研究中,1997年2月/3月对来自澳大利亚新南威尔士州的随机抽取的8年级(平均年龄13.1岁;n = 1072)和10年级(平均年龄15.1岁;n = 954)高中生进行了多级体能测试。学生们在同一天完成了自我报告工具。在信度研究中使用了8年级(n = 121)和10年级(n = 105)学生的独立样本。问卷在相隔两周的两个时间点对相同的学生进行发放,并评估重测信度。根据学生对问卷项目的综合回答,将其分为活跃或活动不足两类。对问卷项目和两类汇总指标评估了kappa值和百分比一致性。
所有被归类为活跃(无论采用何种测量方法)的学生组(8年级和10年级的男生和女生)的有氧适能均显著高于被归类为活动不足的学生。由于二项分布高度偏态,汇总指标重测信度的kappa值远低于百分比一致性。对于8年级男生和女生,百分比一致性分别为67%和70%,对于10年级男生和女生,百分比一致性分别为85%和70%。
这些关于参与高强度身体活动的简短自我报告问题似乎具有可接受的信度和效度。这些工具需要在其他文化中进行测试,以确保研究结果并非澳大利亚学生所特有。应考虑对这些测量方法进行进一步完善。