Martin N
Department of Philosophy, University of Portland, Portland, OR 97202, USA.
J Med Philos. 2001 Aug;26(4):431-41. doi: 10.1076/jmep.26.4.431.3008.
Feminist bioethics is a relatively new field, the major works in which only started to appear in the late 1980s. At first feminist bioethicists focused mainly on issues of particular concern to women such as reproduction. Recently, papers have begun to appear that show that a feminist analysis can be brought to bear on any subject traditional bioethics discusses. So far, however, feminist bioethics has not been brought to bear on psychiatry. There have been feminist critiques of psychiatry and feminist discussions of certain diagnostic categories that disproportionately affect women, but these are concerned with women's issues within psychiatry and how psychiatry has been used to oppress women. Certainly these are important, but what has been missing is a discussion of psychiatry in the sense that feminist bioethics suggests a general critique of psychiatry and the rethinking of the practice of psychiatry, regardless of whether the specific instances involved are women's issues. In this paper I look at what such a feminist bioethical intervention into psychiatry would look like.
女性主义生物伦理学是一个相对较新的领域,其主要著作直到20世纪80年代末才开始出现。起初,女性主义生物伦理学家主要关注女性特别关心的问题,比如生殖问题。最近,一些论文开始出现,表明女性主义分析可以应用于传统生物伦理学所讨论的任何主题。然而,到目前为止,女性主义生物伦理学尚未应用于精神病学领域。已经有对精神病学的女性主义批判,以及对某些不成比例地影响女性的诊断类别的女性主义讨论,但这些都关注精神病学领域内的女性问题,以及精神病学是如何被用来压迫女性的。当然,这些都很重要,但所缺少的是从女性主义生物伦理学所建议的对精神病学进行总体批判和重新思考精神病学实践的意义上对精神病学的讨论,无论所涉及的具体事例是否为女性问题。在本文中,我将探讨这样一种女性主义生物伦理学对精神病学的干预会是什么样子。