Peppin J F
Department of Internal Medicine, St. Joseph's Hospital, Marshfield, WI 54449, USA.
J Med Humanit. 1993 Winter;14(4):203-22. doi: 10.1007/BF01137235.
Since osteopathic medicine's inception its distinction has been proclaimed steadfastly in the osteopathic literature. The uniqueness has been claimed to reside in: (1) rigid adherence to A.T. Still's tenets; (2) osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT); (3) claims of "holism"; (4) "osteopathic principles", (5) esoteric definitions; and (6) other suggested differences. None of these claims can be successfully defended. An aspect of the osteopathic distinction may lie in the didactic of OMT per se. Certain experiences in medical school contribute to the "reconstruction" of the student's view of the patient. Touch, through OMT, may be a quality that affects this change and helps make the osteopathic physician different. When blended with traditional medical modalities this may result in a unique medical perspective. The ideal approach for the osteopathic profession would be an honest evaluation of its function in society and its uniqueness in medicine. The profession may discover a uniqueness with touch as an integral part.
自整骨医学创立以来,其独特性在整骨医学文献中一直被坚定地宣称。其独特性据称在于:(1)严格遵循A.T. 斯蒂尔的原则;(2)整骨手法治疗(OMT);(3)“整体论”的主张;(4)“整骨原则”;(5)深奥的定义;以及(6)其他所谓的差异。这些主张无一能够得到成功辩护。整骨医学独特性的一个方面可能在于OMT本身的教学方法。医学院的某些经历有助于学生对患者看法的“重塑”。通过OMT进行触摸,可能是一种影响这种变化并有助于使整骨医生与众不同的特质。当与传统医学模式相结合时,这可能会产生一种独特的医学视角。整骨医学专业的理想做法是诚实地评估其在社会中的作用及其在医学中的独特性。该专业可能会发现以触摸为不可或缺部分的独特性。