Fossati P, Ergis A M, Allilaire J F
Service de Psychiatrie d'Adultes (Professeur Allilaire), Hôpital Pitié-Salpêtrière, 47, boulevard de l'Hôpital, 75651 Paris cedex 13.
Encephale. 2002 Mar-Apr;28(2):97-107.
While several neuropsychological studies have demonstrated that cognitive deficits are seen across a broad range of cognitive domains, executive deficits associated with frontal lobe dysfunction may be prominent in depression. Executive function refers to cognitive processes that control and integrate other cognitive activities such as episodic memory. These executive functions involve a set of cognitive behaviors which include: dealing with novelty, selecting strategies, inhibiting incorrect responses, monitoring performance and using feedback to adjust future responding. The measurement of executive function relies mainly on the use of neuropsychological tests known to be sensitive to frontal lobe damage such as the Wisconsin and California Card Sorting Tests, verbal fluency tests, Stroop-test, Tower of London Task and Trail Making Test. The present review focuses on studies investigating executive functions in primary unipolar depression with these neuropsychological tasks. Unipolar depressed patients mainly exhibit cognitive inhibition deficits, problem-solving impairments and planning deficits. Cognitive inhibition deficits in depressed patients have been related to a reduction of cognitive resources and psychomotor retardation. Inhibition disturbance could lead depressed patients to process irrelevant information and consequently reduce their capacity to control transient mood changes. Several studies have found evidence of problem solving impairments in depressed patients. Depressed subjects show with card sorting tests difficulties in hypothesis testing with a loss of spontaneous and reactive cognitive flexibility. The cognitive rigidity and hypothesis-testing associated with dorsolateral prefrontal dysfunction in depression may prevent patients to cope with life events and lead to a perpetuation of depressed mood by a continuation of stress exposure. Planning tasks, such as the Tower of London Test, also demonstrate that depressed patients fail to use negative feedback as a motivational boost to improve their performance. Both trait and state factors influence the executive level of depressed patients. Executive deficits have been reported in more severely depressed subjects with melancholic or psychotic features. Executive functioning also might predict a poorer outcome in depression. Thus initiation and perseveration scores - a measure of cognitive flexibility - is associated with relapse and recurrence of depression and residual depressive symptoms. Brain imaging studies show that reduced blood flow, particularly in medial prefrontal cortex and dorsal anterior cingulate cortex subserve executive impairments in depression. However neuroimaging studies underscore the importance of mood-cognitive interactions in depression. A recent working model of depression (Mayberg et al., 1999) implicates failure of the coordinated interactions of distributed cortical-limbic pathways in the neuropsychopathology of depression. According to this model, neocortical (prefrontal and parietal regions) and superior limbic elements (dorsal anterior cingulate) are postulated to mediate impaired attention and executive function, whereas ventral limbic regions (ventral anterior cingulate, subcortical structures) are postulated to mediate circadian and vegetative aspects of depression. Further studies are needed to validate this model at the neuropsychological level as well as the brain level and to elucidate the complex interactions between mood, cognitive resources and executive function in depression.
虽然多项神经心理学研究表明,认知缺陷在广泛的认知领域中都有出现,但与额叶功能障碍相关的执行功能缺陷在抑郁症中可能较为突出。执行功能是指控制和整合其他认知活动(如情景记忆)的认知过程。这些执行功能涉及一系列认知行为,包括:应对新奇事物、选择策略、抑制错误反应、监控表现以及利用反馈来调整未来的反应。执行功能的测量主要依赖于使用已知对额叶损伤敏感的神经心理学测试,如威斯康星卡片分类测验和加利福尼亚卡片分类测验、言语流畅性测试、斯特鲁普测验、伦敦塔任务和连线测验。本综述聚焦于利用这些神经心理学任务对原发性单相抑郁症患者的执行功能进行研究的相关文献。单相抑郁症患者主要表现出认知抑制缺陷、解决问题能力受损和计划缺陷。抑郁症患者的认知抑制缺陷与认知资源减少和精神运动迟缓有关。抑制障碍可能导致抑郁症患者处理无关信息,从而降低他们控制短暂情绪变化的能力。多项研究发现了抑郁症患者存在解决问题能力受损的证据。抑郁症患者在卡片分类测试中表现出在假设检验方面存在困难,且丧失了自发的和反应性的认知灵活性。抑郁症中与背外侧前额叶功能障碍相关的认知僵化和假设检验可能会使患者难以应对生活事件,并通过持续暴露于压力而导致抑郁情绪持续存在。计划任务,如伦敦塔测验,也表明抑郁症患者无法将负面反馈作为提高表现的动力。特质因素和状态因素都会影响抑郁症患者的执行功能水平。在具有忧郁或精神病特征的重度抑郁症患者中报告了执行功能缺陷。执行功能也可能预示着抑郁症的预后较差。因此,起始和持续得分(一种认知灵活性的测量指标)与抑郁症的复发和残留抑郁症状相关。脑成像研究表明,血流量减少,特别是在内侧前额叶皮质和背侧前扣带回皮质区域,与抑郁症中的执行功能障碍有关。然而,神经影像学研究强调了情绪 - 认知相互作用在抑郁症中的重要性。最近的一个抑郁症工作模型(梅伯格等人,1999年)表明,在抑郁症的神经心理病理学中,分布式皮质 - 边缘通路的协调相互作用失败。根据这个模型,新皮质(前额叶和顶叶区域)和高级边缘元素(背侧前扣带回)被假定介导注意力和执行功能受损,而腹侧边缘区域(腹侧前扣带回、皮质下结构)被假定介导抑郁症的昼夜节律和植物神经方面。需要进一步的研究在神经心理学层面以及脑层面验证这个模型,并阐明抑郁症中情绪、认知资源和执行功能之间的复杂相互作用。