Brenner Richard P
Department of Neurology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pennsylvania, USA.
Epilepsia. 2002;43 Suppl 3:103-13. doi: 10.1046/j.1528-1157.43.s.3.9.x.
Nonconvulsive status epilepticus (NCSE) is difficult to diagnose in the obtunded/comatose patient. Such patients often have other serious medical conditions, and the diagnosis is frequently delayed. We review criteria for diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of NCSE in this setting. Terms that have been used to describe SE in obtunded/comatose patients without tonic-clonic convulsions include subtle generalized SE, electrographic SE, SE in comatose patients, generalized electrographic SE, non-tonic-clonic SE, subclinical SE, and NCSE. Sometimes the same term has been used when describing different disorders, and different terms are often applied for the same entity. The incidence of NCSE in obtunded/comatose patients is uncertain. Clinically they may display subtle, intermittent focal or multifocal rhythmic movements suggestive of seizures; there may not be movements. NCSE can occur in a variety of disorders, including hypoxia, metabolic disturbances, and after convulsive seizures. A number of EEG patterns have been described in NCSE, and many of these are controversial, particularly as to whether they are ictal. These include periodic lateralized epileptiform discharges (PLEDS), bilateral independent PLEDS (BIPLEDS), periodic epileptiform discharges (PEDS), which can be either focal or generalized, and generalized triphasic waves (TWs). The diagnostic criteria for NCSE also are controversial, and there are no agreed-on criteria to diagnose NCSE in obtunded/comatose patients, nor is there consensus on how it should it be treated. Furthermore, outcome is poor, and several studies suggest that treatment may not be helpful.
非惊厥性癫痫持续状态(NCSE)在意识模糊/昏迷患者中难以诊断。这类患者通常还患有其他严重的疾病,诊断往往会延迟。我们在此回顾这种情况下NCSE的诊断、治疗及预后标准。用于描述意识模糊/昏迷且无强直阵挛性惊厥患者的癫痫持续状态(SE)的术语包括隐匿性全身性SE、脑电图SE、昏迷患者的SE、全身性脑电图SE、非强直阵挛性SE、亚临床SE和NCSE。有时在描述不同疾病时会使用相同的术语,而对于同一实体往往会应用不同的术语。意识模糊/昏迷患者中NCSE的发病率尚不确定。临床上,他们可能表现出提示癫痫发作的细微、间歇性局灶性或多灶性节律性运动;也可能没有运动。NCSE可发生于多种疾病,包括缺氧、代谢紊乱以及惊厥性发作后。NCSE中已描述了多种脑电图模式,其中许多存在争议,尤其是关于它们是否为发作期模式。这些模式包括周期性一侧性癫痫样放电(PLEDS)、双侧独立PLEDS(BIPLEDS)、周期性癫痫样放电(PEDS,可为局灶性或全身性)以及全身性三相波(TWs)。NCSE的诊断标准也存在争议,对于意识模糊/昏迷患者,尚无公认的诊断NCSE的标准,对于其治疗方法也未达成共识。此外,预后较差,多项研究表明治疗可能并无帮助。