Robertson Heather A, MacKinnon Neil J
College of Pharmacy, and School of Health Services Administration, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Clin Ther. 2002 Oct;24(10):1595-613. doi: 10.1016/s0149-2918(02)80063-7.
Older patients (aged >65 years) may experience drug-related problems that, if unrecognized, can result in drug-related morbidities (DRMs). According to the literature, 49% to 76% of all DRMs may be preventable; however, there is little consensus as to which are preventable and which are not.
The aim of this study was to develop consensus-approved clinical indicators of preventable DRM (PDRM) in older adults. Geriatricians, clinical pharmacologists, general practitioners, and clinical pharmacists were included in the consensus-building process.
In 2001, a survey containing potential indicators of PDRM was prepared based on previous research and the input of 2 clinical pharmacists. The survey was administered concurrently via the Delphi technique to 2 separate specialist panels (6 geriatricians and 6 clinical pharmacologists) to generate clinical indicators of PDRMs in older adults. Subsequently, a focus group of 12 general practitioners (GPs) assessed these PDRM indicators in Nova Scotia, Canada.
The specialist panels generated 58 consensus-approved clinical indicators of PDRMs in older adults after 2 rounds of the Delphi technique. The GPs agreed with 52 (90%) of these PDRM indicators.
This study generated consensus-approved indicators of PDRMs in older adults, which could be used by health professionals to identify patients at risk for PDRMs. The indicators could also have a role in quality measurement systems and in epidemiologic research. Furthermore, the indicators could complement existing clinical indicators and establish an important link between patterns of care and clinical outcomes.
老年患者(年龄>65岁)可能会出现与药物相关的问题,如果未被识别,可能会导致药物相关疾病(DRM)。根据文献,所有DRM中有49%至76%可能是可预防的;然而,对于哪些是可预防的,哪些是不可预防的,几乎没有共识。
本研究的目的是制定经共识认可的老年人可预防DRM(PDRM)的临床指标。老年病学家、临床药理学家、全科医生和临床药师参与了共识建立过程。
2001年,基于先前的研究和两名临床药师的意见,编制了一份包含PDRM潜在指标的调查问卷。该问卷通过德尔菲技术同时分发给两个独立的专家小组(6名老年病学家和6名临床药理学家),以生成老年人PDRM的临床指标。随后,一个由12名全科医生组成的焦点小组在加拿大新斯科舍省对这些PDRM指标进行了评估。
经过两轮德尔菲技术,专家小组生成了58个经共识认可的老年人PDRM临床指标。全科医生同意其中52个(90%)PDRM指标。
本研究生成了经共识认可的老年人PDRM指标,卫生专业人员可利用这些指标识别有PDRM风险的患者。这些指标在质量测量系统和流行病学研究中也可能发挥作用。此外,这些指标可以补充现有的临床指标,并在护理模式和临床结果之间建立重要联系。