Zhang Liqiang, Luan Xinyong, Pan Xinliang, Xie Guang, Xu Fenglei, Liu Dayu, Lei Dapeng
Department of Otolaryngology, Qilu Hospital of Shandong University, Jinan 250012, China.
Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2002 Nov 10;82(21):1461-3.
To explore the surgical methods for laryngeal cancer and long-term effects of larygectomy.
625 cases of laryngeal cancer at different stages, including 182 cases of supraglottic cancer, 429 cases of glottic cancer, and 14 cases of subglottic cancer, underwent operation of different kinds from 1979 to 1999. Radiotherapy was given to those with poorly differentiated squamous carcinoma or with metastasis of cervical lymph nodes postoperatively. The effects of operation, especially that on the preservation of laryngeal function was analyzed.
Partial laryngectomy was performed on 521 of the 625 cases (83.4%) and 203 of the 305 cases at stages III and IV (66.6%). The decannulation rate was 84.07% in the cases undergoing partial laryngectomy. The nasal feeding tube was removed and peroral feeding was recovered in all patients. All cases undergoing partial laryngectomy succeeded in phonation. The overall 3-year survival rate was 89.63% and the overall 5-year survival rate was 77.36%. For the cases with laryngeal cancer at stages III and IV, the 3-year survival rate among those undergoing partial laryngectomy was 84.9%, not significantly different from that among those cases undergoing total laryngectomy (87.7%, P > 0.05); the 5-year survival rate was 66.6% among those undergoing partial laryngectomy and was 69.7% among those undergoing totals laryngectomy (P > 0.05).
The rate of partial laryngectomy is rather high in this group. It is possible to preserve the laryngeal function without compromising the remote survival rate. The prerequisite for the preservation of laryngeal function is to master and choose the proper renovation methods.
探讨喉癌的手术方法及喉切除术的远期效果。
1979年至1999年,对625例不同分期的喉癌患者进行手术,其中声门上癌182例,声门癌429例,声门下癌14例。对术后病理为低分化鳞癌或有颈部淋巴结转移者给予放疗。分析手术效果,尤其是对喉功能保留的影响。
625例患者中521例(83.4%)行部分喉切除术,Ⅲ、Ⅳ期305例患者中203例(66.6%)行部分喉切除术。部分喉切除术患者的拔管率为84.07%。所有患者均拔除鼻饲管,恢复经口进食。所有行部分喉切除术的患者均发声成功。总体3年生存率为89.63%,总体5年生存率为77.36%。Ⅲ、Ⅳ期喉癌患者中,部分喉切除术患者的3年生存率为84.9%,与全喉切除术患者的3年生存率(87.7%)差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);部分喉切除术患者的5年生存率为66.6%,全喉切除术患者的5年生存率为69.7%(P>0.05)。
该组患者部分喉切除术比例较高。在不影响远期生存率的前提下保留喉功能是可行的。保留喉功能的前提是掌握并选择合适的修复方法。