Reis Ben Y, Pagano Marcello, Mandl Kenneth D
Children's Hospital Boston, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2003 Feb 18;100(4):1961-5. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0335026100. Epub 2003 Feb 6.
Current efforts to detect covert bioterrorist attacks from increases in hospital visit rates are plagued by the unpredictable nature of these rates. Although many current systems evaluate hospital visit data 1 day at a time, we investigate evaluating multiple days at once to lessen the effects of this unpredictability and to improve both the timeliness and sensitivity of detection. To test this approach, we introduce simulated disease outbreaks of varying shapes, magnitudes, and durations into 10 years of historical daily visit data from a major tertiary-care metropolitan teaching hospital. We then investigate the effectiveness of using multiday temporal filters for detecting these simulated outbreaks within the noisy environment of the historical visit data. Our results show that compared with the standard 1-day approach, the multiday detection approach significantly increases detection sensitivity and decreases latency while maintaining a high specificity. We conclude that current biosurveillance systems should incorporate a wider temporal context to improve their effectiveness. Furthermore, for increased robustness and performance, hybrid systems should be developed to capitalize on the complementary strengths of different types of temporal filters.
当前试图通过医院就诊率的增加来检测隐蔽生物恐怖袭击的努力,因这些比率的不可预测性而受到困扰。尽管许多现有系统每天评估一次医院就诊数据,但我们研究一次性评估多天的数据,以减轻这种不可预测性的影响,并提高检测的及时性和敏感性。为了测试这种方法,我们将不同形状、规模和持续时间的模拟疾病爆发引入一家大型三级护理都市教学医院的10年历史每日就诊数据中。然后,我们研究在历史就诊数据的嘈杂环境中使用多日时间过滤器检测这些模拟爆发的有效性。我们的结果表明,与标准的单日方法相比,多日检测方法显著提高了检测敏感性,减少了延迟,同时保持了高特异性。我们得出结论,当前的生物监测系统应纳入更广泛的时间背景以提高其有效性。此外,为了增强稳健性和性能,应开发混合系统,以利用不同类型时间过滤器的互补优势。