Sanguineti Giuseppe, Marcenaro Michela, Franzone Paola, Foppiano Franca, Vitale Vito
Department of Radiation Oncology, National Institute for Cancer Research, Genoa, Italy.
Radiother Oncol. 2003 Feb;66(2):151-7. doi: 10.1016/s0167-8140(03)00031-8.
The shrinking effect of 3-month neoadjuvant androgen deprivation (NAD) on preradiotherapy prostate gland volume is well documented. However, recently, it has been shown that the cancerous prostate gland keeps shrinking up to 12 months after NAD start. Thus, if such a reduction is not taken into account, a larger than planned portion of the surrounding normal tissues might shift in the high-dose region during conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT) course. The present study was undertaken to quantify this issue.
Prostate gland volume reduction between planning CT (plCT) and the last week of 3DCRT (tmtCT) was prospectively assessed in 33 consecutive patients with localized prostate carcinoma. The median time interval between plCT and tmtCT was 2.5 months (2.1-2.7 months). A single observer was asked to draw on each slice prostate gland volume as appropriate. The observer was 'blind' to the timing of CT (plCT vs. tmtCT). In order to estimate intra-observer variability, prostate gland delineation was repeated twice for each data set. Mean prostate gland change, plCT and tmtCT cumulative dose volume histogram (DVH) calculations for the rectum were analyzed for each patient. Results were correlated to AD status and its duration before plCT. Means were compared by non-parametric rank tests.
Based on an internal protocol, 14 patients (42%) did not receive AD, while 19 patients (58%) had undergone neoadjuvant and concomitant AD. The median duration of AD before plCT ranged from 0.2 to 6 months (median: 2.9 months). Although individual data were highly variable, compared to plCT volume, mean prostate gland volume change at the end of 3DCRT was similar for patients receiving (-7.3%) or not (-7%) androgen deprivation (P=0.77). However, within the group of patients treated with hormones, patients starting AD within 3 months from plCT had a significantly larger reduction in prostate volume (-14.2%) than patients with longer NAD duration (-1.1%, P=0.03). At tmtCT, on average, patients undergoing 3DCRT within 3 months from AD start showed an increase of the amount of rectum receiving 40-75 Gy compared to plCT values. At 40 Gy (V40) the mean difference between tmtCT and plCT was +7.5%. In the other two groups, average variations of V40-70 were within +/-2% of plCT values. However, these differences are not significant.
For patients who undergo plCT and 3DCRT shortly after AD start, prostate gland shrinkage may be substantial. In some of these patients, this might lead to an unexpected increase of the percentage of rectal wall exposed to intermediate doses.
3个月新辅助雄激素剥夺(NAD)对放疗前前列腺体积的缩小作用已有充分记录。然而,最近研究表明,癌性前列腺在NAD开始后长达12个月仍持续缩小。因此,如果不考虑这种缩小,在适形放疗(3DCRT)过程中,周围正常组织中比计划更大的部分可能会转移到高剂量区域。本研究旨在对这一问题进行量化。
前瞻性评估33例局限性前列腺癌连续患者在计划CT(plCT)和3DCRT最后一周(tmtCT)之间前列腺体积的减少情况。plCT和tmtCT之间的中位时间间隔为2.5个月(2.1 - 2.7个月)。要求一名观察者在每个层面上酌情勾勒出前列腺体积。观察者对CT时间(plCT与tmtCT)“不知情”。为了估计观察者内的变异性,对每个数据集的前列腺轮廓进行了两次重复勾勒。分析了每位患者的平均前列腺变化、plCT和tmtCT直肠累积剂量体积直方图(DVH)计算结果。结果与AD状态及其在plCT之前的持续时间相关。采用非参数秩检验比较均值。
根据内部方案,14例患者(42%)未接受AD,而19例患者(58%)接受了新辅助和同步AD。plCT之前AD的中位持续时间为0.2至6个月(中位数:2.9个月)。尽管个体数据差异很大,但与plCT体积相比,接受(-7.3%)或未接受(-7%)雄激素剥夺的患者在3DCRT结束时的平均前列腺体积变化相似(P = 0.77)。然而,在接受激素治疗的患者组中,在距plCT 3个月内开始AD的患者前列腺体积缩小明显更大(-14.2%),而NAD持续时间较长的患者缩小较小(-1.1%,P = 0.03)。在tmtCT时,平均而言,从AD开始3个月内接受3DCRT的患者与plCT值相比,接受40 - 75 Gy直肠量增加。在40 Gy(V40)时,tmtCT和plCT之间的平均差异为 +7.5%。在其他两组中,V40 - 70的平均变化在plCT值的±2%以内。然而,这些差异不显著。
对于在AD开始后不久接受plCT和3DCRT的患者,前列腺缩小可能很显著。在其中一些患者中,这可能导致暴露于中等剂量直肠壁百分比意外增加。