Luby Elliot D, Singareddy Ravi Kumar
Comprehensive Psychiatric Services, Farmington Hills, Michigan, USA.
Bipolar Disord. 2003 Feb;5(1):62-8. doi: 10.1034/j.1399-5618.2003.01206.x.
To document the effectiveness and vicissitudes of treating 14 bipolar patients with lithium carbonate over a combined 300 years, and an average of 21 years/patient.
Chart review of the narrative and laboratory studies of these 14 patients ranging in duration from 12 to 29 years.
Lithium stabilized these bipolar patients over these periods. Only three patients required hospitalization, one because lithium was slowly tapered at her request after 6 years of mood stability, another because of non-compliance, and a third because of co-morbid alcohol abuse. One patient attempted suicide after lithium was tapered off. However, in some patients, there were serious side-effects necessitating lithium discontinuation.
Controlled studies in psychopharmacology are obviously preferred to open-label or naturalistic case studies. However, controlled studies are rarely conducted over long periods, and practice-related naturalistic research can be of value, albeit anecdotal and without the use of structured rating scales. In this paper, we are reporting on 14 patients seen consistently by one psychiatrist. These patients were functional and productive at work and in family life. The patients suffered brief hypomanic or depressive episodes. Although several patients experienced serious side-effects, lithium was continued with stable mood, while the side-effects were managed in collaboration with other specialists.
记录300年(平均每位患者21年)里使用碳酸锂治疗14例双相情感障碍患者的疗效及变化情况。
对这14例患者历时12至29年的病历叙述及实验室研究进行回顾分析。
在这些时间段内,碳酸锂使这些双相情感障碍患者的病情得以稳定。只有3例患者需要住院治疗,1例是因为在情绪稳定6年后应其要求逐渐减少碳酸锂用量,另1例是因为未遵医嘱,第3例是因为并发酒精滥用。1例患者在碳酸锂减量后企图自杀。然而,部分患者出现严重副作用,不得不停用碳酸锂。
精神药理学领域的对照研究显然优于开放标签或自然观察性病例研究。然而,对照研究很少长期进行,与实践相关的自然观察性研究虽属轶事且未使用结构化评定量表,但仍可能具有价值。在本文中,我们报告了一位精神科医生持续诊治的14例患者。这些患者在工作和家庭生活中功能良好且富有成效。患者经历过短暂的轻躁狂或抑郁发作。尽管部分患者出现严重副作用,但在情绪稳定的情况下仍继续使用碳酸锂,并与其他专科医生合作处理副作用。