Scott Tim, Mannion Russell, Davies Huw T O, Marshall Martin N
Department of Health Sciences, University of York, Heslington, UK.
Int J Qual Health Care. 2003 Apr;15(2):111-8. doi: 10.1093/intqhc/mzg021.
To review some of the key debates relating to the nature of organizational culture and culture change care organizations and systems.
A literature review was conducted that covered both theoretical contributions and published studies of the processes and outcomes of culture change programmes across a range of health and non-health care settings.
There is little consensus among scholars over the precise meaning of organizational culture. Competing claims exist concerning whether organizational cultures are capable of being shaped by external manipulation to beneficial effect. A range of culture change models has been developed. A number of underlying factors that commonly attenuate culture change programmes can be identified. Key factors that appear to impede culture change across a range of sectors include: inadequate or inappropriate leadership; constraints imposed by external stakeholders and professional allegiances; perceived lack of ownership; and subcultural diversity within health care organizations and systems.
Managing organizational culture is increasingly viewed as an essential part of health system reform. To transform the culture of a whole health system such as the UK National Health Service would be a complex, multi-level, and uncertain process, comprising a range of interlocking strategies and supporting tactics unfolding over a period of years.
回顾一些与医疗机构和系统中组织文化的本质及文化变革相关的关键争论。
进行了一项文献综述,涵盖了理论贡献以及在一系列卫生保健和非卫生保健环境中文化变革项目的过程与结果的已发表研究。
学者们对于组织文化的确切含义几乎没有达成共识。关于组织文化是否能够通过外部操纵塑造以产生有益效果,存在相互竞争的观点。已经开发了一系列文化变革模型。可以确定一些通常会削弱文化变革项目的潜在因素。在一系列部门中似乎阻碍文化变革的关键因素包括:领导不足或不当;外部利益相关者和专业忠诚所施加的限制;感觉缺乏自主权;以及卫生保健组织和系统内的亚文化多样性。
管理组织文化越来越被视为卫生系统改革的重要组成部分。要改变整个卫生系统的文化,如英国国民医疗服务体系,将是一个复杂、多层次且不确定的过程,包括一系列相互关联的战略和多年来展开的支持策略。