Honkavaara M, Rintasalo E, Ylönen J, Pudas T
University of Oulu.
Dtsch Tierarztl Wochenschr. 2003 Mar;110(3):125-8.
This study evaluated the effect of transport time up to 14 hours and the effects of vehicle design on animal welfare, stress and meat quality. 18 transports (six short, medium and long) with a total of 486 animals (118 sample animals, heifers and bulls) were carried out on commercial vehicles in summer 2000 and winter 2001. Animal welfare and stress were evaluated by blood serum parameters, heart rate monitoring, behaviour recording and occurrence of carcass bruising. Meat quality was evaluated by post mortem muscle glycogen content, pH value, temperature, drip loss, colour and tenderness measurements. Heifers had lower heart rates than young bulls during loading (95 vs 114 beats per minute, bpm), whereas during transport, both had an average heart rate of 100 bpm, furthermore during unloading, heifers had higher heart rates than bulls (109 vs 100 bpm). Blood sampling during unloading could have marginally increased heart rates during the unloading procedure. Studied cattle had lower heart rates during medium and long distance transports compared with short transports. Monitoring of animal behaviour during transport showed that the former settled down faster than the latter. Single- and two-animal pens in medium and long distance vehicles prevented nervous and stressful movements of cattle, which were more prominent in large pens of short distance lorry. Present results suggest that larger pens of three or four animals could increase cattle stress during transport. Moreover during unloading, cattle loaded in single- or two-animals pens had significantly lower blood cortisol content than those loaded in larger groups of three or four animals (P < 0.01). The amount of severe carcass bruising was highest in animals transported over short times and loaded into groups of four cattle. Severe damages occurred most often on perianal and hipbone area of the carcass surface. Present results showed that muscle glycogen level was highest after long transport. These animals were fed more regularly from the last feeding up to stunning than medium or short distance animals. Animals in single-pens had the highest muscle glycogen level. Transport distance or number of animals in one pen had a minor effect on muscle pH values or temperatures during 24 hours post mortem (pm). Drip loss of the M. longissimus dorsi (LD) was highest after long transport, but animal number in one pen had no effect on drip loss. Colour of the LD muscle was independent on transport conditions. Light colour of three animal groups resulted from high amounts of heifers, which had lighter colour than bulls. All meat samples were quite tender. However, heifers had significantly tender meat than young bulls (P < 0.001). Higher amounts of heifers had the most tender meat after short transports. Mean DFD (dark, firm, dry) meat occurrence was 2.1% in this project, DFD frequency was lowest after short, then after long and highest after medium distance transports. Because of not evenly distributed numbers of bulls (low) and heifers (high) it was difficult to compare short and long distance transport effects.
本研究评估了长达14小时的运输时间以及车辆设计对动物福利、应激和肉质的影响。2000年夏季和2001年冬季,在商用车辆上进行了18次运输(6次短途、6次中途和6次长途),共有486头动物(118头采样动物,包括小母牛和公牛)。通过血清参数、心率监测、行为记录和胴体擦伤情况评估动物福利和应激。通过宰后肌肉糖原含量、pH值、温度、滴水损失、颜色和嫩度测量评估肉质。在装载过程中,小母牛的心率低于年轻公牛(95次/分钟对114次/分钟,bpm),而在运输过程中,两者的平均心率均为100 bpm,此外,在卸载过程中,小母牛的心率高于公牛(109次/分钟对100次/分钟)。卸载过程中的采血可能在一定程度上增加了卸载过程中的心率。与短途运输相比,研究中的牛在中途和长途运输期间心率较低。运输过程中对动物行为的监测表明,前者比后者更快安定下来。中途和长途运输车辆中的单只和两只动物围栏可防止牛出现紧张和应激行为,而在短途货车的大围栏中这种行为更为明显。目前的结果表明,三只或四只动物的较大围栏可能会增加运输过程中牛的应激。此外,在卸载过程中,单只或两只动物围栏中装载的牛的血液皮质醇含量明显低于三只或四只动物的较大群体中装载的牛(P < 0.01)。在短时间运输并装入四只牛一组的动物中,胴体严重擦伤的数量最多。严重损伤最常发生在胴体表面的肛周和髋骨区域。目前的结果表明,长时间运输后肌肉糖原水平最高。与中途或短途运输的动物相比,这些动物从最后一次喂食到致昏期间喂食更规律。单围栏中的动物肌肉糖原水平最高。运输距离或围栏中的动物数量对宰后24小时(pm)内的肌肉pH值或温度影响较小。长时间运输后,背最长肌(LD)的滴水损失最高,但围栏中的动物数量对滴水损失没有影响。LD肌肉的颜色与运输条件无关。三只动物组的浅色是由于小母牛数量较多,小母牛的颜色比公牛浅。所有肉样都相当嫩。然而,小母牛的肉比年轻公牛的肉明显更嫩(P < 0.001)。短途运输后,小母牛数量较多的肉最嫩。本项目中平均DFD(深色、坚硬、干燥)肉的发生率为2.1%,DFD频率在短途运输后最低,其次是长途运输,中途运输后最高。由于公牛(数量少)和小母牛(数量多)分布不均,难以比较短途和长途运输的影响。