Indersmitten Tim, Gur Ruben C
Brain Behavior Laboratory, Department of Psychiatry, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104, USA.
J Neurosci. 2003 May 1;23(9):3820-5. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.23-09-03820.2003.
Since the discovery of facial asymmetries in emotional expressions of humans and other primates, hypotheses have related the greater left-hemiface intensity to right-hemispheric dominance in emotion processing. However, the difficulty of creating true frontal views of facial expressions in two-dimensional photographs has confounded efforts to better understand the phenomenon. We have recently described a method for obtaining three-dimensional photographs of posed and evoked emotional expressions and used these stimuli to investigate both intensity of expression and accuracy of recognizing emotion in chimeric faces constructed from only left- or right-side composites. The participant population included 38 (19 male, 19 female) African-American, Caucasian, and Asian adults. They were presented with chimeric composites generated from faces of eight actors and eight actresses showing four emotions: happiness, sadness, anger, and fear, each in posed and evoked conditions. We replicated the finding that emotions are expressed more intensely in the left hemiface for all emotions and conditions, with the exception of evoked anger, which was expressed more intensely in the right hemiface. In contrast, the results indicated that emotional expressions are recognized more efficiently in the right hemiface, indicating that the right hemiface expresses emotions more accurately. The double dissociation between the laterality of expression intensity and that of recognition efficiency supports the notion that the two kinds of processes may have distinct neural substrates. Evoked anger is uniquely expressed more intensely and accurately on the side of the face that projects to the viewer's right hemisphere, dominant in emotion recognition.
自从在人类和其他灵长类动物的情绪表达中发现面部不对称以来,已有假说将左半面部表情强度更高与情绪处理中的右半球优势联系起来。然而,在二维照片中创建面部表情的真实正视图存在困难,这使得人们在更好地理解这一现象方面的努力受到了干扰。我们最近描述了一种获取摆拍和诱发情绪表情三维照片的方法,并使用这些刺激来研究表情强度以及从仅由左侧或右侧合成图像构建的嵌合面孔中识别情绪的准确性。参与研究的人群包括38名(19名男性,19名女性)非裔美国人、白人和亚洲成年人。他们观看了由八名男演员和八名女演员的面孔生成的嵌合合成图像,这些面孔展现了四种情绪:快乐、悲伤、愤怒和恐惧,每种情绪都有摆拍和诱发两种情况。我们重复了这一发现:除了诱发愤怒在右半面部表达更强烈外,在所有情绪和情况下,情绪在左半面部的表达都更强烈。相比之下,结果表明情绪表情在右半面部能被更有效地识别,这表明右半面部表达情绪更准确。表情强度的偏向性与识别效率的偏向性之间的双重分离支持了这样一种观点,即这两种过程可能具有不同的神经基质。诱发愤怒在投射到观看者右半球(在情绪识别中占主导地位)一侧的面部独特地表现得更强烈且更准确。