Conaghan Philip, Lassere Marissa, Østergaard Mikkel, Peterfy Charles, McQueen Fiona, O'Connor Philip, Bird Paul, Ejbjerg Bo, Klarlund Mette, Shnier Ron, Genant Harry, Emery Paul, Edmonds John
Academic Unit of Musculoskeletal and Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Leeds, UK.
J Rheumatol. 2003 Jun;30(6):1376-9.
The aim of this multireader, multicenter study was to assess the inter-reader reliability of the score in the assessment of disease status and progression. The exercise involved 10 sets of metacarpophalangeal (MCP, 2nd to 5th) joints and 10 sets of wrist magnetic resonance images that were scored by experienced readers from 5 international centers. Synovitis was scored for each site using a global score (0-3). Bone abnormalities were assessed at 8 MCP joint sites and 15 wrist sites according to proportion of bone volume (0-10 for erosions and defects and 0-3 for edema). Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and smallest detectable differences for synovitis, erosions, and edema were acceptable, although better for status scores than progression scores. The agreement for MCP joints was better than wrists. Limited variation in the images for some findings resulted in low ICC. Bone defects had the poorest agreement and have been omitted from new scoring recommendations. Despite limited training, multicenter readers demonstrated acceptable levels of agreement.
这项多读者、多中心研究的目的是评估在疾病状态和进展评估中评分的读者间可靠性。该活动涉及10组掌指关节(第2至5掌指关节)和10组腕部磁共振图像,由来自5个国际中心的经验丰富的读者进行评分。使用整体评分(0 - 3)对每个部位的滑膜炎进行评分。根据骨体积比例,在8个掌指关节部位和15个腕部部位评估骨异常情况(侵蚀和缺损为0 - 10,水肿为0 - 3)。尽管状态评分的组内相关系数(ICC)和最小可检测差异比进展评分更好,但滑膜炎、侵蚀和水肿的ICC和最小可检测差异是可接受的。掌指关节的一致性优于腕部。某些发现的图像变化有限导致ICC较低。骨缺损的一致性最差,已从新的评分建议中省略。尽管培训有限,但多中心读者表现出了可接受的一致性水平。