Giannini E, Botta F, Borro P, Risso D, Romagnoli P, Fasoli A, Mele M R, Testa E, Mansi C, Savarino V, Testa R
Gastroenterology Unit, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Genoa, Italy.
Gut. 2003 Aug;52(8):1200-5. doi: 10.1136/gut.52.8.1200.
Cirrhotic patients frequently undergo screening endoscopy for the presence of oesophageal varices (OV). In the future, this social and medical burden will increase due to the greater number of patients with chronic liver disease and their improved survival. In this study, our aims were (1) to identify clinical, biochemical, and ultrasonographic parameters which might non-invasively predict the presence of OV in patients with liver cirrhosis; (2) to evaluate the reproducibility of the obtained results in a different, although related, further group of patients; and (3) to assess the predictiveness of the identified rules in patients with compensated cirrhosis.
In the first part of the study we retrospectively evaluated the presence of OV in 145 cirrhotic patients, and in the second part we evaluated the reproducibility of the study results in a subsequent group of 121 patients. Finally, we evaluated these parameters in a subgroup of 145 patients with compensated disease. All 266 patients underwent a complete biochemical workup, upper digestive endoscopy, and ultrasonographic measurement of spleen bipolar diameter. Platelet count/spleen diameter ratio was calculated for all patients.
The prevalence rates of OV were 61% and 58% in the first and second groups of patients, respectively. In the first part of the study, we found that platelet count, spleen diameter, platelet count/spleen diameter ratio, and Child- Pugh class were significantly different among patients with or without OV, although the platelet count/spleen diameter ratio was the only parameter which was independently associated with the presence of OV in a multivariate analysis. A platelet count/spleen diameter ratio cut off value of 909 had 100% negative predictive value for a diagnosis of OV. This result was reproduced in the second group of patients as well as in patients with compensated disease. In a cost-benefit analysis, screening cirrhotic patients according to the "platelet count/spleen diameter ratio strategy" was far more cost effective compared with the "scope all strategy".
The platelet count/spleen diameter ratio is the only parameter which is independently associated with the presence of OV, and its negative predictive value is reproducible. Its use is of value even in the subgroup of patients with compensated disease, and it is also cost effective.
肝硬化患者常因食管静脉曲张(OV)而接受内镜筛查。未来,由于慢性肝病患者数量增加且生存率提高,这种社会和医疗负担将会加重。在本研究中,我们的目的是:(1)确定可能无创预测肝硬化患者OV存在的临床、生化和超声参数;(2)在另一组相关的患者中评估所得结果的可重复性;(3)评估所确定规则对代偿期肝硬化患者的预测性。
在研究的第一部分,我们回顾性评估了145例肝硬化患者中OV的存在情况,在第二部分中,我们评估了后续121例患者中研究结果的可重复性。最后,我们在145例代偿期疾病患者的亚组中评估了这些参数。所有266例患者均接受了全面的生化检查、上消化道内镜检查以及脾脏双极直径的超声测量。计算了所有患者的血小板计数/脾脏直径比值。
第一组和第二组患者中OV的患病率分别为61%和58%。在研究的第一部分,我们发现血小板计数、脾脏直径、血小板计数/脾脏直径比值和Child-Pugh分级在有或无OV的患者中存在显著差异,尽管在多因素分析中血小板计数/脾脏直径比值是唯一与OV存在独立相关的参数。血小板计数/脾脏直径比值截断值为909时,对OV诊断的阴性预测值为100%。这一结果在第二组患者以及代偿期疾病患者中也得到了重现。在成本效益分析中,与“全面内镜检查策略”相比,根据“血小板计数/脾脏直径比值策略”对肝硬化患者进行筛查具有更高的成本效益。
血小板计数/脾脏直径比值是唯一与OV存在独立相关的参数,其阴性预测值具有可重复性。即使在代偿期疾病患者亚组中使用它也有价值,而且具有成本效益。