Manfredi Paolo L, Breuer Brenda, Wallenstein Sylvan, Stegmann Marian, Bottomley Gail, Libow Leslie
The Jewish Home and Hospital, New York, USA.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2003 Aug;18(8):700-5. doi: 10.1002/gps.906.
Some patients with advanced dementia cannot convey the experience of pain verbally and may react to pain with aggressive and agitated behaviors. We hypothesized that unrecognized pain could contribute to agitation and that low dose opioid therapy might reduce agitation by reducing pain. We therefore attempted to determine the effect of opioids on agitation in demented patients.
We administered placebo for 4 weeks and a long-acting opioid for another 4 weeks to nursing home patients with advanced dementia and severe agitation despite treatment with psychotropic drugs. Patients and study nurses did not know if the medication administered was placebo or opioid. We measured the Cohen-Mansfield Agitation Inventory (CMAI) score at baseline and every two weeks.
Among 47 patients who entered the study, 25 completed the two phases. The median age for the 25 patients was 85.5 years. Analyses of the data of these 25 patients and of the patients <85 years-old showed no significant differences in agitation level between the placebo and opioid phases. However, among the 13 patients who completed the study and were > or =85 years old, the agitation level at the end of the opioid phase was significantly lower than at the end of the placebo phase (mean change in CMAI score: -6.4; 95% confidence interval (CI): -10.96, -1.8). The decrease in agitation in the patients > or =85 years old persisted after adjusting for sedation. The results remained unchanged when we expanded the analyses to include four > or =85 patients who dropped out of the study after the second week of the opioid phase.
Low dose, long-acting opioids can lessen agitation that is difficult to control in very old (> or =85) patients with advanced dementia.
一些晚期痴呆患者无法用言语表达疼痛体验,可能会以攻击和激越行为对疼痛做出反应。我们推测未被识别的疼痛可能导致激越,低剂量阿片类药物治疗可能通过减轻疼痛来减少激越。因此,我们试图确定阿片类药物对痴呆患者激越的影响。
我们对患有晚期痴呆且尽管使用了精神药物仍有严重激越的养老院患者,先给予4周安慰剂,再给予4周长效阿片类药物。患者和研究护士不知道所给予的药物是安慰剂还是阿片类药物。我们在基线时以及每两周测量一次科恩-曼斯菲尔德激越量表(CMAI)评分。
47名进入研究的患者中,25名完成了两个阶段。这25名患者的中位年龄为85.5岁。对这25名患者以及年龄<85岁患者的数据进行分析,结果显示安慰剂阶段和阿片类药物阶段的激越水平无显著差异。然而,在完成研究且年龄≥85岁的13名患者中,阿片类药物阶段结束时的激越水平显著低于安慰剂阶段结束时(CMAI评分的平均变化:-6.4;95%置信区间(CI):-10.96,-1.8)。在调整镇静因素后,年龄≥85岁患者的激越减少仍持续存在。当我们将分析范围扩大到包括4名在阿片类药物阶段第二周后退出研究的年龄≥85岁患者时,结果保持不变。
低剂量长效阿片类药物可减轻极老年(≥85岁)晚期痴呆患者难以控制的激越。