Heindel W, Datené S, Lauterbach K, Gandjour A
Institut für Radiologische Diagnostik, Klinikum der Universität zu Köln.
Rofo. 2003 Sep;175(9):1207-13. doi: 10.1055/s-2003-41939.
To analyze prospectively abdominal ultrasound in an emergency department (ED) with special emphasis on different routes of obtaining radiology service, reasons for consultation and ordering diagnosis, and to identify strategies for realizing cost savings.
Over a three-month period, the course of events of 295 patients, who entered the ED and underwent on-call sonography, was recorded from the initial presentation to the commencement of treatment, and the results were subsequently evaluated.
Of all patients sonographically examined in the ED, 60 % had no prior contact to ambulatory medical services (self-referred, S), 15 % had been sent by a physician (physician-referred, P), and 25 % were inpatients. The most frequent reason for consultation was acute abdominal pain in self-referred patients (70 %) and blunt abdominal trauma in physician-referred patients (70 %). Sonography for acute abdominal pain was considered indicated by the examining radiologist prior to the examination in 90 % (P) and 70 % (S). Sonography contributed to the diagnosis in 44 % (P) and 22 % (S). Patients had to be hospitalized in 80 % (P) and 40 % (S), and needed immediate treatment in 78 % (P) and 43 % (S). Sonography after blunt abdominal trauma was considered appropriate in 90 % (P) and 65 % (S). Diagnostic information was obtained in 90 % (P) and 88 % (S), and therapeutic interventions were required in 10 % (P) and 0 % (S). The admission rate was 97 % (P) and 29 % (S), respectively.
In the ED, sonography was performed with significantly lower clinical effectiveness on self-referred than on physician-referred patients. Substantial cost-savings could be achieved by more selective use of abdominal sonography for self-referred patients.
前瞻性分析急诊科腹部超声检查情况,特别关注获取放射科服务的不同途径、会诊及开具诊断的原因,并确定实现成本节约的策略。
在三个月期间,记录了295例进入急诊科并接受急诊超声检查患者从首次就诊到开始治疗的事件过程,随后对结果进行评估。
在急诊科接受超声检查的所有患者中,60%此前未联系过门诊医疗服务(自行就诊,S),15%由医生转诊(医生转诊,P),25%为住院患者。自行就诊患者会诊的最常见原因是急性腹痛(70%),医生转诊患者是钝性腹部创伤(70%)。对于急性腹痛,在检查前,90%(P)和70%(S)的检查放射科医生认为超声检查是必要的。超声检查对诊断有帮助的比例在P组为44%,S组为22%。P组80%、S组40%的患者需要住院,P组78%、S组43%的患者需要立即治疗。钝性腹部创伤后超声检查,P组90%、S组65%认为是合适的。P组90%、S组88%获得了诊断信息,P组10%、S组0%需要进行治疗干预。住院率分别为P组97%、S组29%。
在急诊科,自行就诊患者超声检查的临床有效性明显低于医生转诊患者。通过更有选择性地对自行就诊患者使用腹部超声检查可实现大量成本节约。