Vowden K R, Wilkinson D, Vowden P
Department of Vascular Surgery, Bradford Royal Infirmary, UK.
J Wound Care. 2001 May;10(5):182-4. doi: 10.12968/jowc.2001.10.5.26075.
This evaluation examined the effectiveness of the K-Four (Parema) high compression bandage system on 50 patients with recalcitrant 'hard-to-heal' venous leg ulcers and relates the outcome to an earlier randomised study which compared three other four-layer bandage systems. Twelve-week healing rates were 53.2% in the current series, which included patients with poor mobility, large ulcers and long pretreatment ulcer duration, rising to 69.5% at 20 weeks. When account was taken of known risk factors for delayed ulcer healing, no significant difference could be identified between between either K-Four or the earlier evaluated bandages, which included the original Charing Cross system, where the overall healing rates were 64.5% and 80%, respectively, at 12 and 20 weeks. It would seem more likely that treatment outcome is related to patient risk factors for delayed healing and bandaging expertise than to the bandage system employed.
本评估研究了K-Four(Parema)高压缩绷带系统对50例顽固性“难愈合”腿部静脉溃疡患者的有效性,并将结果与早期一项比较其他三种四层绷带系统的随机研究进行关联。在本系列研究中,12周愈合率为53.2%,其中包括行动不便、溃疡面积大以及预处理溃疡持续时间长的患者,20周时升至69.5%。考虑到已知的溃疡愈合延迟风险因素,K-Four与早期评估的绷带(包括最初的查令十字系统)之间未发现显著差异,在12周和20周时,后者的总体愈合率分别为64.5%和80%。治疗结果似乎更有可能与患者愈合延迟的风险因素和绷带包扎专业知识有关,而非所采用的绷带系统。