Baylon G J, Chung F
Department of Anaesthesia, University of Toronto, Ontario.
Can J Anaesth. 1992 Sep;39(7):643-8. doi: 10.1007/BF03008223.
Learning needs assessment is the term applied to the process of identifying or diagnosing a learner's educational needs. It is the foundation of a systematic continuing medical education (CME) programme. Needs assessment has been identified as the most pressing problem of medical education directors in North America. Furthermore, the CME learning needs, interests or motivations of anaesthetists have never been studied. The amount of time and effort required for needs assessment is probably a major deterrent to this activity. The investigators adopted simple and straightforward means of assessing the "perceived learning needs" and topic interests of anaesthetists. Questionnaires were sent by mail to anaesthetists practicing in teaching and non-teaching hospitals in the Toronto area. The questionnaire presented a list of CME content areas. The respondents were asked to indicate on scale of 1 to 10 their Current Expertise, Ideal-Desired Expertise, and Interest-Motivation levels for each content area. Need Score for each content area was calculated by taking the difference between Ideal and Current Expertise responses. A total of 101/305 anaesthetists (29%) responded to the survey. Most of the respondents had been in anaesthesia practice for less than ten years. Regional nerve block, acute pain control, and medicolegal considerations received high overall ranks in both the need and interest categories. Paediatric anaesthesia, anaesthesia for trauma surgery and thoracic anaesthesia had top ranks among the subspecialty fields. Regional anaesthesia techniques received higher need and interest ranks than intravenous and inhalational techniques. The learning needs of anaesthetists of a large urban centre have been identified, and this information is useful to CME planners.
学习需求评估是指用于识别或诊断学习者教育需求的过程。它是系统的继续医学教育(CME)项目的基础。需求评估已被确定为北美医学教育主任最紧迫的问题。此外,麻醉医生的CME学习需求、兴趣或动机从未被研究过。需求评估所需的时间和精力可能是这项活动的主要阻碍因素。研究人员采用了简单直接的方法来评估麻醉医生的“感知学习需求”和主题兴趣。通过邮件向多伦多地区教学医院和非教学医院的麻醉医生发送问卷。问卷列出了CME内容领域清单。要求受访者针对每个内容领域,在1至10的量表上表明他们当前的专业水平、理想的专业水平以及兴趣 - 动机水平。每个内容领域的需求得分通过计算理想专业水平和当前专业水平回答之间的差异得出。共有101名/305名麻醉医生(29%)回复了调查。大多数受访者从事麻醉工作不到十年。区域神经阻滞、急性疼痛控制和法医学考量在需求和兴趣类别中总体排名都很高。小儿麻醉、创伤手术麻醉和胸科麻醉在亚专业领域中排名靠前。区域麻醉技术的需求和兴趣排名高于静脉和吸入技术。已确定了一个大型城市中心麻醉医生的学习需求,这些信息对CME规划者有用。