Schmalzried T P, Harris W H
Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1992 Sep;74(8):1130-9.
The results of eighty-three consecutive primary total hip arthroplasties in which a Harris-Galante porous-coated acetabular component had been used were reviewed after a minimum of five years. In all patients, the stated diameter of the acetabular component (the diameter printed on the packaging for the implant) used was equal to the stated diameter of the reamer (the diameter printed on the reamer) that had been used last in the preparation of the acetabulum. As there was little or no press-fit stability, stability was obtained initially with multiple transfixing screws. No component was revised because of loosening, and none were radiographically loose at an average of sixty-eight months and a maximum of seven years after the operation. There was no evidence of disruption of the titanium porous mesh, and no screw had bent or broken. Two sockets, however, had been revised because of failure of the liner-locking mechanism as well as disassociation of the polyethylene liner from the titanium-alloy shell. Lysis of bone occurred in only one patient, around one screw. Areas of non-contact (gaps) between the porous mesh at the periphery of the acetabular component and the bone were seen on the immediate postoperative radiographs of nearly half of the patients. New areas of radiolucency, which had not been seen immediately postoperatively, were identified at two years in forty-nine hips. These radiolucent lines were never wider than one millimeter and were most frequently located in zone 3 and, less frequently, in zone 1. At the time of the most recent follow-up evaluation, a progressive radiolucent line was identified around twenty-two components and a discontinuous radiolucent line was present in all three zones around eleven components. No continuous radiolucent line was identified at the mesh-bone interface of any component. These results are superior to our results with cemented acetabular components after a similar period of follow-up. A longer period of follow-up is needed before the importance of these thin radiolucent lines can be determined, but experience with cemented acetabular components indicates that progressive or extensive radiolucent lines, or both, may represent resorption of bone at the porous mesh-bone interface and this can lead to loosening of the component. Our data suggest that the technique used for implantation may be important not only for the initial fixation and ingrowth of bone, but also for the long-term durability of the fixation of a porous-coated acetabular component.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
对连续83例使用Harris-Galante多孔涂层髋臼组件的初次全髋关节置换术患者进行了至少5年的随访。所有患者使用的髋臼组件标称直径(印在植入物包装上的直径)与髋臼准备过程中最后使用的扩孔钻标称直径(印在扩孔钻上的直径)相等。由于几乎没有或完全没有压配稳定性,最初通过多根固定螺钉获得稳定性。没有因松动而翻修的组件,术后平均68个月、最长7年时,影像学检查也没有发现组件松动。没有证据表明钛多孔网破裂,也没有螺钉弯曲或折断。然而,有两个髋臼杯因衬垫锁定机制故障以及聚乙烯衬垫与钛合金外壳分离而进行了翻修。仅1例患者出现1枚螺钉周围的骨质溶解。近半数患者术后即刻X线片显示髋臼组件周边多孔网与骨之间存在非接触区(间隙)。49髋在术后2年发现了术后即刻未见的新的透亮区。这些透亮线从未超过1毫米,最常见于3区,较少见于1区。在最近一次随访评估时,22个组件周围发现有进展性透亮线,11个组件周围所有三个区均存在间断性透亮线。任何组件的网-骨界面均未发现连续的透亮线。这些结果优于我们在相似随访期内使用骨水泥固定髋臼组件的结果。在确定这些细透亮线的重要性之前,需要更长时间的随访,但骨水泥固定髋臼组件的经验表明,进展性或广泛性透亮线,或两者皆有,可能代表多孔网-骨界面处的骨质吸收,这可能导致组件松动。我们的数据表明,植入技术不仅对骨的初始固定和长入很重要,而且对多孔涂层髋臼组件固定的长期耐久性也很重要。(摘要截选至400字)