Clohisy J C, Harris W H
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999 Jan;81(1):66-73. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199901000-00010.
Two hundred and thirty-seven consecutive primary acetabular reconstructions were performed, in 213 patients, with use of a Harris-Galante porous-coated acetabular component with screw fixation between January 1984 and December 1987. Twenty-four patients (twenty-seven hips) died before a minimum duration of follow-up of eighty-four months, five patients (five hips) were too ill to return for a detailed follow-up examination at the time of the study, four patients (four hips) refused clinical and radiographic follow-up (but one of these patients had more than eighty-four months of follow-up for one side of a bilateral total hip replacement), two patients (two hips) were lost to follow-up, and two patients (two hips) refused radiographic follow-up but had adequate clinical follow-up. In addition, one patient who had had a bilateral total hip replacement had a resection arthroplasty on one side because of a late infection 115 months after the index procedure. Thus, 196 hips (83 per cent) in 177 patients were available for radiographic and clinical review after an average duration of follow-up of 122 months (range, eighty-four to 155 months). The average age of these 177 patients at the time of the operation was fifty-nine years (range, twenty-three to eighty-seven years). Eight well fixed acetabular shells (4 percent) were revised: three were revised because of dissociation of the liner in association with fractures of the tines, three were revised during revision of the femoral component, and two were revised because of retroacetabular osteolysis. In eight other hips, the acetabular liner was exchanged during revision of a loose femoral component. No acetabular component migrated, was classified as radiographically loose, or was revised because of aseptic loosening. There was no evidence of fragmentation or disruption of the titanium porous mesh of any cup. One of 528 screws broke. There were no complications associated with the insertion of the acetabular fixation screws. Osteolytic lesions were identified adjacent to nine (5 percent) of the 188 acetabular components that were in place at the time of the most recent examination. One hip, which had discontinuous osteolytic lesions in all three acetabular zones, was treated with bone-grafting around the well fixed acetabular component. Eight hips had a discontinuous radiolucent line that was 1.0 millimeter wide or less in all three zones and another two had a continuous radiolucent line that was 0.5 millimeter wide in all three zones. The average Harris hip score for the 188 hips (169 patients) that did not have revision of the acetabular shell improved from 47 points (range, 22 to 71 points) preoperatively to 89 points (range, 35 to 100 points) at the time of the latest examination. One hundred and thirty-four hips had an excellent result; twenty-six, a good result; nineteen, a fair result; and nine, a poor result. All nine hips that had a poor result were in patients who had other factors, unrelated to the acetabular component, that contributed to the low Harris hip score. In the present study, the Harris-Galante porous-coated acetabular component continued to provide excellent fixation and clinical results for most patients at an average of approximately ten years after the operation.
1984年1月至1987年12月期间,对213例患者连续进行了237次初次髋臼重建手术,使用的是带螺钉固定的Harris-Galante多孔涂层髋臼组件。24例患者(27髋)在至少随访84个月之前死亡,5例患者(5髋)病情过重,在研究时无法返回进行详细的随访检查,4例患者(4髋)拒绝临床和影像学随访(但其中1例患者双侧全髋关节置换的一侧有超过84个月的随访),2例患者(2髋)失访,2例患者(2髋)拒绝影像学随访但有充分的临床随访。此外,1例双侧全髋关节置换患者在初次手术后115个月因晚期感染对一侧进行了切除关节成形术。因此,177例患者中的196髋(83%)在平均随访122个月(范围84至155个月)后可进行影像学和临床复查。这177例患者手术时的平均年龄为59岁(范围23至87岁)。8个固定良好的髋臼杯(4%)进行了翻修:3个因衬垫分离合并齿部骨折而翻修,3个在股骨组件翻修时进行了翻修,2个因髋臼后缘骨溶解而翻修。另外8髋在翻修松动的股骨组件时更换了髋臼衬垫。没有髋臼组件发生移位、影像学上被归类为松动或因无菌性松动而翻修。没有证据表明任何髋臼杯的钛多孔网有碎裂或破坏。528枚螺钉中有1枚断裂。髋臼固定螺钉的插入没有相关并发症发生。在最近一次检查时,188个在位髋臼组件中有9个(5%)相邻出现骨溶解病变区。1髋在所有三个髋臼区域都有不连续的骨溶解病变区,则在固定良好的髋臼组件周围进行了植骨治疗。8髋在所有三个区域都有宽度为1.0毫米或更小的不连续透光线,另外2髋在所有三个区域都有宽度为0.5毫米的连续透光线。188髋(169例患者)未进行髋臼杯翻修的平均Harris髋关节评分从术前的47分(范围22至71分)提高到最近一次检查时的89分(范围35至100分)。134髋结果为优;26髋为良;19髋为中;9髋为差。所有9例结果为差的髋均见于有其他与髋臼组件无关因素导致Harris髋关节评分低的患者。在本研究中,Harris-Galante多孔涂层髋臼组件在术后平均约十年时,对大多数患者仍能持续提供良好的固定效果和临床结果。