Stansfeld S A, Marmot M G
Academic Department of Psychiatry, University College and Middlesex Hospital School of Medicine, London.
Psychol Med. 1992 Aug;22(3):739-49. doi: 10.1017/s0033291700038186.
Major psychiatric disorder is more common in people of lower rather than higher socioeconomic status. This is less clear for the commoner, so-called minor psychiatric disorders, but these are more affected by tendency to report symptoms. To examine this the distribution of minor psychiatric disorder by employment grade measured by the 30-item General Health Questionnaire is reported from the first cross-sectional phase of the Whitehall II Study of 10,314 London-based civil servants, men and women between 35 and 55 years. Validation of the GHQ in a random subsample stratified by grade and sex (N = 201) suggested that people in lower employment grades tend to under-report minor psychiatric disorder on the GHQ relative to those in higher employment grades. The prevalence of minor psychiatric disorder corrected by the coefficients from the validity study was greater in the lower employment grades than the higher employment grades particularly for men. This was echoed in grade differences in well-being measured by the Affect Balance Scale, and in symptoms and recurrent health problems. Overall, for women there were few clear-cut differences in minor psychiatric disorder by employment grade. The lack of social class gradient in women suggests that further exploration should examine women's role at work and their personal lives for the aetiology of minor psychiatric disorder.
严重精神障碍在社会经济地位较低而非较高的人群中更为常见。对于较为常见的所谓轻度精神障碍而言,情况则不太明确,但这些障碍更容易受到症状报告倾向的影响。为了对此进行研究,我们从白厅II研究的第一个横断面阶段报告了以30项一般健康问卷衡量的就业等级与轻度精神障碍分布之间的关系,该研究涉及10314名伦敦公务员,年龄在35至55岁之间,包括男性和女性。在按等级和性别分层的随机子样本(N = 201)中对一般健康问卷进行验证表明,相对于高就业等级的人,低就业等级的人在一般健康问卷上往往会少报轻度精神障碍。根据效度研究得出的系数校正后的轻度精神障碍患病率在低就业等级中高于高就业等级,尤其是男性。这在情感平衡量表衡量的幸福感等级差异以及症状和反复出现的健康问题中得到了体现。总体而言,女性在轻度精神障碍方面按就业等级划分几乎没有明显差异。女性缺乏社会阶层梯度表明,应进一步探索女性在工作和个人生活中的角色,以寻找轻度精神障碍的病因。