Larnach T A, Boyd S J, Smart R C, Butler S P, Rohl P G, Diamond T H
Department of Nuclear Medicine, St. George Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Calcif Tissue Int. 1992 Oct;51(4):255-8. doi: 10.1007/BF00334484.
Reproducibility of lateral spine dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (LAT DEXA) scans using a Lunar DPX-L scanner was assessed in a cadaveric phantom and in patients. One hundred phantom measurements over 7 months demonstrated a longitudinal stability of 1.7% (coefficient of variation, CV). Additional scans were performed with the phantom rotated by up to 20 degrees in each of the three orthogonal planes to assess the effects of variable patient positioning. Horizontal and vertical rotation of the spine had little effect on the estimated bone mineral density (BMD), however, axial rotation of greater than 8 degrees led to errors in the BMD measurement. One hundred consecutive patients had two lateral scans performed within 1 month. BMD (range 0.10-1.6 g/cm2) was determined for each scan by one operator. Significant overlap from ribs and pelvis was often seen with L2 and L4 vertebrae but one vertebra (L3) could be measured in every case. Intraoperator and interoperator variability was assessed by three experienced operators, each analyzing 10 patients' scans on five separate occasions, and was found to be less than 1.1% for a single vertebra. BMD estimation of vertebral bodies and midslices by lateral DEXA scans (CV% of 3.8% and 4.6%) have a 95% confidence interval of 0.074 g/cm2 and 0.096 g/cm2, respectively for two vertebrae. This variability is due mainly to axial rotation, with operator variability, horizontal rotation, and vertical rotation having little effect on BMD estimation.
使用Lunar DPX-L扫描仪对脊柱侧位双能X线吸收法(LAT DEXA)扫描的可重复性在尸体模型和患者中进行了评估。在7个月内进行的100次模型测量显示纵向稳定性为1.7%(变异系数,CV)。对模型在三个正交平面中每个平面最多旋转20度进行额外扫描,以评估患者体位变化的影响。脊柱的水平和垂直旋转对估计的骨矿物质密度(BMD)影响很小,然而,大于8度的轴向旋转会导致BMD测量出现误差。100名连续患者在1个月内进行了两次脊柱侧位扫描。由一名操作人员对每次扫描测定BMD(范围为0.10 - 1.6 g/cm²)。经常可见L2和L4椎体与肋骨和骨盆有明显重叠,但每个病例中均能测量一个椎体(L3)。由三名经验丰富的操作人员评估操作人员内和操作人员间的变异性,每人在五个不同场合分析10名患者的扫描图像,发现单个椎体的变异性小于1.1%。通过侧位DEXA扫描对椎体和中间切片的BMD估计(CV%分别为3.8%和4.6%),对于两个椎体,95%置信区间分别为0.074 g/cm²和0.