Chesters R K, Huntington E, Burchell C K, Stephen K W
Unilever Dental Research, Port Sunlight Laboratory, Bebington, UK.
Caries Res. 1992;26(4):299-304. doi: 10.1159/000261456.
Data on toothbrushing habits were collected during a 3-year caries clinical trial of sodium monofluorophosphate toothpastes in Lanarkshire, Scotland, involving 3,005 schoolchildren of mean age 12.5 years at baseline. Stated normal brushing frequency and oral rinsing method after brushing were recorded. Half the panel indicated they rinsed their mouths after toothbrushing using a beaker. The proportion of the panel brushing once per day or more increased during the trial. Differences in oral habits were observed between the sexes, with 42% of girls and 52% of boys being non-beaker rinsers and 73% of girls, but only 44% of boys, brushing their teeth at least twice per day. Twice-a-day brushers had a consistently lower caries increment than less frequent brushers. This was also seen in the baseline prevalence data, but did not account for all incremental differences noted. Subjects using beakers had consistently higher increments than non-beaker rinsers. Again, this difference could not be explained by variations in baseline prevalence. Differences in the caries increment were also observed between boys and girls, these appearing to be linked both to the cumulative effect of male/female habit variations plus a difference in the baseline caries prevalence. A dose response to the three fluoride levels, i.e 1,000, 1,500, and 2,500 ppm F, was seen for the different habit combinations which again could not be explained by differences in the baseline caries prevalence.
在苏格兰拉纳克郡开展的一项为期3年的单氟磷酸钠牙膏龋齿临床试验中,收集了有关刷牙习惯的数据。该试验涉及3005名学童,基线时平均年龄为12.5岁。记录了宣称的正常刷牙频率以及刷牙后的口腔冲洗方法。有一半的受试者表示他们刷牙后用烧杯漱口。在试验期间,每天刷牙一次或更多次的受试者比例有所增加。观察到不同性别在口腔习惯上存在差异,42%的女孩和52%的男孩不用烧杯漱口,73%的女孩每天至少刷牙两次,而男孩只有44%。每天刷牙两次的人龋齿增量始终低于刷牙频率较低的人。这在基线患病率数据中也有体现,但并未解释所有观察到的增量差异。使用烧杯漱口的受试者龋齿增量始终高于不用烧杯漱口的人。同样,这种差异无法用基线患病率的变化来解释。男孩和女孩在龋齿增量上也存在差异,这似乎既与男女习惯差异的累积效应有关,也与基线龋齿患病率的差异有关。对于不同的习惯组合,观察到了对三种氟含量水平(即1000、1500和2500 ppm F)的剂量反应,同样,这也无法用基线龋齿患病率的差异来解释。