Egelund E, Jeppesen F
Dept. of O.R.L., Viborg Hospital, Viborg, Denmark.
Rhinology. 1992 Sep;30(3):193-204.
The use of packings following septorhinoplasty is a matter of controversy. The recommendations go from gluing with fibrin glue only, if anything at all, over quilting stitches, perhaps in combination with silastic or teflon sheats or plates or these sheats alone, to the employment of various more substantial materials and in from 1 to even 14 days postoperatively. If long-term nasal packing is chosen following consideration of primary healing, patients will experience discomfort of mouth-breathing, but pressure in the ears, too. Therefore, our department has used respiratory tubes simultaneously with packings since 1971. In this study, 47 patients who underwent septo- and/or rhinoplasty were treated by nasal packings 6 days postoperatively. All patients were treated by silicone respiratory tubes, one group in all 6 days, one in 4 days only. Self-assessment as far as some typical complaints is concerned was carried out as well as tympanometry. There were statistically significant less complaints of pressure in the ears when tubes were used, and the period with tubes was significantly preferred to the period without. A low pressure in the middle ears was seen in many patients. The normalization was occurring significantly sooner with tubes. At the same time they seem to secure that the normalization will take place as fast as it has been demonstrated in an earlier study employing only 3 days of nasal packing. No synechias or perforations were seen at an early follow-up, 1-3 months postoperatively. When long-term packing is preferred, respiratory tubes then can be recommended as effective.
鼻中隔鼻成形术后使用填充物存在争议。建议范围从仅使用纤维蛋白胶粘合(若有使用的话),到采用缝合法,可能会结合硅橡胶或特氟龙片或板,或仅使用这些片材,再到使用各种更坚固的材料,术后使用时间从1天到甚至14天不等。如果在考虑一期愈合后选择长期鼻腔填塞,患者会经历口呼吸不适,同时耳部也会有压力感。因此,自1971年以来,我们科室在使用填充物的同时也使用了呼吸管。在本研究中,47例行鼻中隔和/或鼻成形术的患者在术后6天接受鼻腔填塞治疗。所有患者均使用硅胶呼吸管,一组使用6天,另一组仅使用4天。就一些典型症状进行了自我评估以及鼓室图检查。使用呼吸管时,耳部压力不适的抱怨在统计学上显著减少,且使用呼吸管的时间段明显比不使用的时间段更受青睐。许多患者中耳出现低压。使用呼吸管时,中耳压力恢复正常的时间明显更早。同时,它们似乎确保了中耳压力能像在一项仅进行3天鼻腔填塞的早期研究中所证明的那样快速恢复正常。在术后1 - 3个月的早期随访中未发现粘连或穿孔。当倾向于长期填塞时,呼吸管可作为有效的推荐使用。