Kahn Bronwen, Lumey L H, Zybert Patricia A, Lorenz John M, Cleary-Goldman Jane, D'Alton Mary E, Robinson Julian N
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Colorado, Denver, Colorado, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 2003 Oct;102(4):685-92. doi: 10.1016/s0029-7844(03)00616-1.
To evaluate the prospective risk of fetal death in singleton, twin, and triplet pregnancies and to compare this risk with fetal and neonatal death rates.
We analyzed 11,061,599 singleton, 297,622 twin, and 15,375 triplet gestations drawn from the 1995-1998 National Center for Health Statistics linked birth and death files. Prospective risk of fetal death was expressed as a proportion of all fetuses still at risk at a given gestational age and compared with fetal death rate. Fetal death risk and neonatal death rates were represented graphically for singletons, twins, and triplets.
The prospective risk of fetal death at 24 weeks was 0.28 per 1000, 0.92 per 1000, and 1.30 per 1000 for singletons, twins, and triplets, respectively. At 40 weeks, the corresponding risk was 0.57 per 1000 and 3.09 per 1000 for singletons and twins, respectively and, at 38 or more weeks, 13.18 per 1000 for triplets. Plots of gestation-specific prospective risk of fetal death and neonatal mortality converged for singletons and twins at term but crossed for triplets at approximately 36 weeks' gestation.
Prospective risk of fetal death is greater for triplets and twins than for singletons and greater for triplets than for twins during the third trimester. The pattern corroborates with uteroplacental insufficiency as a suspected underlying mechanism. When prospective risk of fetal death exceeds neonatal mortality risk, delivery might be indicated. When this model is used, this data set suggests that it might be reasonable to consider delivery of twins by 39 weeks and triplets by 36 weeks to improve perinatal outcome.
评估单胎、双胎和三胎妊娠中胎儿死亡的前瞻性风险,并将该风险与胎儿及新生儿死亡率进行比较。
我们分析了从1995 - 1998年国家卫生统计中心的出生与死亡关联档案中提取的11061599例单胎、297622例双胎和15375例三胎妊娠。胎儿死亡的前瞻性风险表示为在特定孕周仍处于风险中的所有胎儿的比例,并与胎儿死亡率进行比较。以图表形式展示单胎、双胎和三胎的胎儿死亡风险及新生儿死亡率。
单胎、双胎和三胎在孕24周时胎儿死亡的前瞻性风险分别为每1000例中有0.28例、0.92例和1.30例。在孕40周时,单胎和双胎的相应风险分别为每1000例中有0.57例和3.09例,而在孕≥38周时,三胎的风险为每1000例中有13.18例。单胎和双胎在足月时特定孕周的胎儿死亡前瞻性风险与新生儿死亡率的曲线相交,但三胎在孕约36周时相交。
三胎和双胎妊娠中胎儿死亡的前瞻性风险高于单胎妊娠,且在孕晚期三胎高于双胎。这种模式证实了子宫胎盘功能不全是一种潜在的可疑机制。当胎儿死亡的前瞻性风险超过新生儿死亡率风险时,可能需要引产。使用该模型时,此数据集表明,为改善围产期结局,考虑在孕39周时对双胎进行引产、在孕36周时对三胎进行引产可能是合理的。