Shea Dennis, Davey Adam, Femia Elia E, Zarit Steven H, Sundström Gerdt, Berg Stig, Smyer Michael A
Department of Health Policy and Administration, Penn State University, University Park, PA, USA.
Gerontologist. 2003 Oct;43(5):712-21. doi: 10.1093/geront/43.5.712.
Few international comparisons of health services are performed using microlevel data. Using such data, this paper compares the need for and receipt of assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs) in comparable samples in the United States and Sweden, a country with a universal system of community-based services.
Data from national surveys of community residents completed at approximately the same time in each nation are used to create comparable measures of need and assistance. Descriptive and logistic regression analyses compare need and assistance patterns across the nations and identify individual factors that explain receipt of assistance and unmet needs.
Our results indicate that a simple story of greater use of paid formal services in Sweden and more unpaid informal use in the United States masks a more complex relationship. Assistance with ADLs seems to be more targeted in Sweden; narrow differences in assistance widen considerably when the analysis is limited to those reporting need.
Although these two different health systems result in similar levels of overall ADL assistance, a detailed microlevel comparison reveals key distinctions. Further microlevel comparisons of access, cost, and quality in cross-national data can further aid our understanding of the consequences of health policy.
很少有利用微观层面数据进行的卫生服务国际比较。本文利用此类数据,比较了美国和瑞典(一个拥有基于社区的普遍服务体系的国家)可比样本中对日常生活活动(ADL)的协助需求及获得情况。
来自两国大致在同一时间完成的社区居民全国性调查的数据,被用于创建需求和协助的可比衡量指标。描述性分析和逻辑回归分析比较了两国间的需求和协助模式,并确定了解释协助获得情况和未满足需求的个体因素。
我们的结果表明,瑞典更多使用付费正规服务而美国更多使用无偿非正规服务这一简单说法掩盖了更为复杂的关系。瑞典对ADL的协助似乎更具针对性;当分析仅限于那些表示有需求的人时,协助方面的细微差异会大幅扩大。
尽管这两种不同的卫生系统在总体ADL协助水平上相似,但详细的微观层面比较揭示了关键差异。对跨国数据中的可及性、成本和质量进行进一步的微观层面比较,可进一步帮助我们理解卫生政策的后果。