Rutherford Andrew, Stephens Richard, Potter Douglas
Department of Psychology, Keele University, Keele, Staffordshire ST5 5BG, United Kingdom.
Neuropsychol Rev. 2003 Sep;13(3):153-79. doi: 10.1023/a:1025525613477.
Association Football (soccer) is the most popular and widespread sport in the world. A significant proportion of the injuries suffered in football are head injuries involving trauma to the brain. In normal play, head trauma frequently arises from collisions, but some researchers have claimed that it also may arise as a consequence of heading the ball. Although assessments based on biomechanical analyses are equivocal on the potential for brain injury due to football heading, a growing literature seems to support the claim that neuropsychological impairment results from general football play and football heading in particular. However, this review suggests a distinction is required between the neuropsychological effects of concussive and subconcussive head trauma and that all of the neuropsychological studies conducted so far suffer from methodological problems. At best, a few of these studies may be regarded as exploratory. The review concludes that presently, although there is exploratory evidence of subclinical neuropsychological impairment as a consequence of football-related concussions, there is no reliable and certainly no definitive evidence that such impairment occurs as a result of general football play or normal football heading. The neuropsychological consequences of football-related subconcussive effects await confirmatory investigation.
英式足球是世界上最受欢迎、分布最广泛的运动。足球运动中相当一部分受伤情况是头部受伤,涉及脑部创伤。在正常比赛中,头部创伤常因碰撞引起,但一些研究人员声称,头球也可能导致头部创伤。尽管基于生物力学分析的评估对于头球导致脑损伤的可能性尚无定论,但越来越多的文献似乎支持这样的观点,即神经心理损伤是由一般足球运动,尤其是头球导致的。然而,本综述表明,脑震荡性和亚脑震荡性头部创伤的神经心理影响之间需要加以区分,而且迄今为止进行的所有神经心理学研究都存在方法学问题。充其量,其中一些研究可被视为探索性的。该综述得出结论,目前,虽然有探索性证据表明与足球相关的脑震荡会导致亚临床神经心理损伤,但没有可靠的、当然也没有确凿的证据表明这种损伤是由一般足球运动或正常头球导致的。与足球相关的亚脑震荡影响的神经心理后果有待进一步的验证性研究。