Bonell C P, Strange V J, Stephenson J M, Oakley A R, Copas A J, Forrest S P, Johnson A M, Black S
Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London, UK.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003 Nov;57(11):871-6. doi: 10.1136/jech.57.11.871.
The UK government argues that "social exclusion" increases risk of teenage pregnancy and that educational factors may be dimensions of such exclusion. The evidence cited by the government is limited to reporting that socioeconomic disadvantage and educational attainment influence risk. Evidence regarding young people's attitude to school is not cited, and there is a lack of research concerning the UK. This paper develops hypotheses on the relation between socioeconomic and educational dimensions of social exclusion, and risk of teenage pregnancy, by examining whether dislike of school and socioeconomic disadvantage are associated with cognitive/behavioural risk measures among 13/14 year olds in English schools.
Analysis of data from the baseline survey of a study of sex education.
13/14 year old school students from south east England.
The results indicate that socioeconomic disadvantage and dislike of school are associated with various risk factors, each with a different pattern. Those disliking school, despite having comparable knowledge to those liking school, were more likely to have sexual intercourse, expect sexual intercourse by age 16, and expect to be parents by the age of 20. For most associations, the crude odds ratios (ORs) and the ORs adjusted for the other exposure were similar, suggesting that inter-confounding between exposures was limited.
It is hypothesised that in determining risk of teenage pregnancy, the two exposures are independent. Those disliking school might be at greater risk of teenage pregnancy because they are more likely to see teenage pregnancy as inevitable or positive.
英国政府认为“社会排斥”会增加青少年怀孕的风险,且教育因素可能是这种排斥的维度。政府所引用的证据仅限于报告社会经济劣势和教育程度会影响风险。未引用有关年轻人对学校态度的证据,且缺乏关于英国的研究。本文通过研究英国学校中13/14岁学生对学校的厌恶和社会经济劣势是否与认知/行为风险指标相关,对社会排斥的社会经济和教育维度与青少年怀孕风险之间的关系提出假设。
对一项性教育研究的基线调查数据进行分析。
来自英格兰东南部的13/14岁在校学生。
结果表明,社会经济劣势和对学校的厌恶与各种风险因素相关,且各有不同模式。那些不喜欢学校的学生,尽管与喜欢学校的学生知识水平相当,但更有可能发生性行为、预计在16岁前发生性行为以及预计在20岁时成为父母。对于大多数关联,粗比值比(OR)和针对其他暴露因素调整后的OR相似,这表明暴露因素之间的相互混杂有限。
据推测,在确定青少年怀孕风险时,这两种暴露因素是独立的。那些不喜欢学校的青少年怀孕风险可能更高,因为他们更有可能认为青少年怀孕是不可避免的或积极的。